Manager Review

Island Park Reservations

Island Park Reservations's guest rating of 4.72 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review Island Park Reservations.

Recent guest reviews

RadineJune 2026Island Park, Idaho
Beautiful setting and great for a family with children .
airbnb
AmyJune 2026Island Park, Idaho
The place looks like the photo. It could use some hooks to hang clothes and for storing items when you stay. It was peaceful and quiet. The bed was comfortable. This place was perfect for our purpose which was to explore Yellowstone for 3 days.
airbnb
JasonJune 2026Island Park, Idaho
We really enjoyed our stay at this cabin for our family trip. The accommodations were very clean and tidy. We did not lack for anything.
airbnb
BrookeJune 2026Island Park, Idaho
We loved island park, everything we needed and wanted was relatively close, a great place to stay while visiting national parks.
airbnb
RyanJune 2026Island Park, Idaho
Great place if you love nature. Even though they have some extra requirements before you leave, it’s a nice and big place for a family or group of friends
airbnb
MeganJune 2026Island Park, Idaho
We really enjoyed our stay at this tiny cabin!!
airbnb
SavannahJune 2026Island Park, Idaho
Cute cabin, we felt at home and comfortable with the area. Nice area
airbnb
TaylorJune 2026Island Park, Idaho
We stayed a week in early June. Our experience: Cleanliness was inconsistent - we found a blood stain on the sheets of one bed on arrival, we had to wash about half the dishes before using them, and the tub drain released debris when we tried to run a bath for our 3 year old. The host did send fresh sheets and refunded the cleaning fee after we raised concerns, which we appreciated. That said, the response was reactive rather than proactive, and only came after direct feedback. There was also active, loud construction in the cabin community directly across from our entryway - not disclosed in the listing - that ran most days of our stay. The cabin has potential, but the cleaning standards and overall guest experience fell short. We would not stay again.
airbnb
TaylorFebruary 2026Island Park, Idaho
This booking is a good location and is a nice base for IP activities. Clean 1 bedroom with kitchen and bathroom. The host seems to be a host that primarily has another reservation company but lists the property on Airbnb as a secondary way to get business. This caused us a lot of trouble. We had to sign forms and agreements outside of the Airbnb app, take screenshots for all instructions, and communicate after hours outside of the app. After doing all this we did not get codes or access instructions in the way they described and had to message them. At the time of this review the listing was 2 bed 2 bath and we were charged at that price. When we arrived I messaged the host for help and they said it was a system error but they couldn’t accommodate what we booked. Other properties of that size owned by the same host were listed for cheaper. The host was kind and gave us $50 back, but at that point it felt like we overpaid. Still enjoyed our stay, but probably wouldn’t book again.
airbnb
JulieFebruary 2026Island Park, Idaho
The place itself is fine - very small but good enough for a couple days. The walls are thin and there is a door adjoining that unit to the next one - if your neighbors snore or have loud kids then it will sound like they’re in the same room. The host is unresponsive and not helpful. We arrived and I realized they never sent me the door code, I had to text the after-hours number to get it. All the communication from the host is just auto-generated messages that go out to any guest staying in any of their units, so you have to read a lot of information that isn’t relevant to your stay and try to figure out what applies to you. Their auto-generated messages failed to include our check in or check out information. They never responded to my messages on the Airbnb platform.
airbnb

Local Rankings