Manager Review

Island Park Cabins & Lodges reviews in Idaho

Island Park Cabins & Lodges's guest reviews across Idaho. See homeowner reviews of Island Park Cabins & Lodges on their profile.

Island Park Cabins & Lodges's guest rating in Idaho of 4.63 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Idaho.

Recent guest reviews

TyeannOctober 2026Island Park
“Great stay! the location was perfect for site seeing and short drive to west yellowstone!”
airbnb
JuliaOctober 2026Island Park
“It was fine since we booked last minute but the place we stayed at in Driggs spoiled us and gave us a much more friendly and personal experience.”
airbnb
BenSeptember 2026Island Park
“Check-in was rough — we arrived around 10 PM and found the beds unmade. To the host's credit, they sent cleaners over quickly and everything was fixed within about an hour. The cabin itself was comfortable once made up. Would stay again, just hope the turnover is more consistent.”
airbnb
AndrewSeptember 2026Island Park
“The cabin was wonderful. Cozy and nicely decorated. We were hoping all the amenities were available and were disappointed that the gas fireplaces and cooking oven was not working during our stay. Communication was quick but not apologetic/concerned about the inconvenience.”
airbnb
BenuJune 2026Island Park
“We stayed at this cabin for two nights during our Yellowstone trip. The cabin itself was comfortable, but we had a concerning experience with the management. One evening, when we returned, we found the door open and the lights on. It’s possible that we accidentally left the door unsecured when we left, but since we weren’t certain, we felt uncomfortable entering and contacted the Airbnb management for assistance. Rather than helping us assess the situation or checking whether everything was safe, the conversation focused on assigning blame and insisting it was our fault. As we didn’t feel safe going inside without knowing whether someone could be in the cabin, we eventually called 911, and the responding officers were very helpful. What disappointed us most was that the Airbnb management never followed up afterward to check if we were okay or if the situation had been resolved. While the property itself was fine, the lack of support and concern during a situation where guest safety”
airbnb

Amongst managers in Idaho, Island Park Cabins & Lodges currently ranks 29/30 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Idaho.