Manager Review

Prime Properties in Fish Haven, Idaho

4.94

This is the local review page for Prime Properties in Fish Haven, Idaho. Amongst managers in Fish Haven, Prime Properties currently ranks 2 of 7 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Fish Haven, or see homeowner reviews of Prime Properties on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

MonetAugust 2026
Hi Jake! Thank you so much for having us. We felt right at home and would love to return some day. We saw the most beautiful stars and moonrises with the unbeatable lake view. We did not spot Izzy the lake monster. All in all we felt very cozy in this private getaway. Such a lovely place. Thanks again :)
airbnb
MistiAugust 2026
Very beautiful plabce and views. I marked 4 stars on the cleaniness only because the cleaners had missed a few things, the host responded very quickly and the issues were resolved. They will be talking to the cleaning company to ensure it doesnt occur again. The beds were so comfortable! And the firepit was perfect for roasting marshmallows. We love north beach so this location was perfect and away from the high traffic of Garden city. We also went to Bloomington Lake for the first time and it was an easy drive from this location too. We saw a ton of wild life while staying here, including a moose at one point! The kids and adults had a great time and the smart tvs were available for thebkifs tonwatch movies while us adults played games! They had just the right type of kid games too so the kids werent on their devices. I would highly recommend this place, especially if you love the outdoors but not camping.
airbnb
BruceAugust 2026
We had a great stay in Fish Haven. The home was perfect for our needs. Jake was responsive to all our questions. Definitely a 5. star home.
airbnb
CoreyJuly 2026
Our stay at Overlook was amazing. The view of bear lake is beautiful. Jake was an excellent host. Highly recommend checking it out!
airbnb
ShellieJuly 2026
We had a great stay at Jake's cabin. He was great to communicate with - extremely friendly and quick to respond. We loved being so close to the north beach and away from the busyness of garden city. I communicated a few issues with cleanliness and upkeep to Jake and the property management who were both very responsive.
airbnb