Manager Review

Coldwell Banker Island Vacations reviews in Waikoloa Village, Hawaii

4.76

Coldwell Banker Island Vacations holds a 4.76 guest rating in Waikoloa Village, Hawaii, computed from 289 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 13 of 17 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Waikoloa Village, or homeowner reviews of Coldwell Banker Island Vacations on their profile.

Coldwell Banker Island Vacations's guest rating in Waikoloa Village, Hawaii of 4.76 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Waikoloa Village.

Recent guest reviews in Waikoloa Village

DespenaOctober 2026
“Pros: 1)Well equipped kitchen 2) Comfortable bed 3)Lots of beach amenities (chairs, boogie boards, etc.) 4)Elevator 5) Location 6)AC & fans worked well 7) Outdoor furniture was fine Cons: 1) Extremely tired 2) Old furniture 3) Tiny tv 4) Heavily stained carpets 5) New microwave and new shower head needed”
airbnb
ClaraOctober 2026
“The property was gorgeous. Condo was tastefully decorated. Things need to be fixed. Asked for king bed three times and they just pushed the two beds together. Coffee machine but no pot. Broken dishwasher. Was told repairman would come by. It didn’t happen.”
airbnb
ConnieOctober 2026
“The condo itself was comfortable, spacious, nicely decorated, and well-equipped with kitchen essentials, beach chairs, and a cooler. Its location was also convenient, with easy access to local dining and shops, with nearby beaches just 15 minutes away. However, several issues impacted our stay. We specifically selected this rental for the hot tub, but upon arrival, it was drained, covered, roped off, and completely unusable. Management failed to inform us of this in advance, and although they provided a small credit, it was still disappointing. Also, a hurricane was forecasted to hit the island around the time of our arrival. When we asked to cancel and receive a refund or credit, the owners refused, forcing us to travel directly into a severe weather warning. When we arrived, state parks, and beaches were all closed, requiring us to stock up on supplies, secure the patio furniture, and shelter in place. Fortunately the island avoided the worst of the storm but it was still stressful.”
airbnb
BethMay 2026
“was a great place to stay! we had trouble with the front gate being broken and then multiple lock boxes at the door. (a keyless entry would be much easier) also, after many requests of the parking pass it was not in the unit as directed. we figured it out, but was not how we wanted to spend our time later at night. overall it was a great stay with excellent location. we enjoyed the open layout and large balcony.”
airbnb
BryceMay 2026
“Our Ohana had the pleasure of staying at this incredibly perfect condo for 11 nights, and we couldn't be happier with our decision. The development is ideally located and close to both The Queen's & The King's Shops, 15 minutes from Waikoloa Village, super close to both Waialea Bay (69 Beach) & Hapuna Beach, with several others (including Kua Bay, my personal favorite), and 5 minutes from A Bay. Kona is relatively close, as well as Waimea (aka Kamuela), so you'll have many options to explore within range of the condo. The cherry on top? You're literally right across from their super cool swimming pool, recreation areas, as well as the fitness center! When we weren't at the beach, we were hanging loose by the pool, Big Island style! Our expectations were exceeded, and many memories were made. 10/10 and would definitely book this condo again. Mahalo nui loa and Aloha! A hui hou!!”
airbnb