Manager Review

Garden Island Rentals in Koloa, Hawaii

4.83

This is the local review page for Garden Island Rentals in Koloa, Hawaii. Amongst managers in Koloa, Garden Island Rentals currently ranks 10 of 32 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Koloa, or see homeowner reviews of Garden Island Rentals on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

ReeceAugust 2026
Nice place
airbnb
HeatherAugust 2026
This house was perfect for our family of four with two teenagers. It was easy to pull the louvered doors closed and separate the Murphy bed and double bed from the main living area. The views and the ocean breeze are spectacular. Almost directly across from Baby Beach and so it is easy to grab the beach chairs, walk across the street and use the outdoor shower to clean off all of the sand and salt once we were home. It is an easy walk to the Kukuiula shopping center and Lawai beach for snorkeling.
airbnb
ChristyAugust 2026
Absolutely gorgeous condo and view! There were so many extras in the condo that were not expected- suntan lotion, window cleaning solution (was very welcomed for the dirty rental car windows), laundry detergent, saran wrap etc. Everything was fantastic. Entire unit was air conditioned along with ceiling fans. Best part was you could hear the ocean from inside the condo. Would absolutely recommend this condo. Will definitely be back to stay in this condo again!
airbnb
SophiaAugust 2026
Really great location, but unfortunately the lack of AC was a huge problem. We also found multiple cockroaches in the house, a few of them in the actual beds. We had to leave half way through our trip. Thankfully they were understanding and we know it wasn’t totally their fault, but it was a huge let down. With a little maintenance and central AC, this place could be worth what they’re charging, but unfortunately it’s just very much not.
airbnb
KimberlyAugust 2026
Had an absolutely wonderful stay. Perfect for our family. Amazing location with short walks to Brennecke and Poipu beach. Poipu beach is perfect for littles with calm waters and daily turtle sightings. The house itself was spacious and we really enjoyed having meals at the long table outdoors. Host was great and made very helpful suggestions.
airbnb