Manager Review

Coldwell Banker Island Vacations reviews in Kihei, Hawaii

4.76

Coldwell Banker Island Vacations holds a 4.76 guest rating in Kihei, Hawaii, computed from 4,613 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 18 of 33 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Kihei, or homeowner reviews of Coldwell Banker Island Vacations on their profile.

Coldwell Banker Island Vacations's guest rating in Kihei, Hawaii of 4.76 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Kihei.

Recent guest reviews in Kihei

SamarOctober 2026
“This was the dirtiest airbnb I have ever stayed in. There were many sanitation and cleanliness issues. The sofa bed was not prepared upon arrival as requested and had visible urine stains on the mattress. The housekeeper that eventually came was not prepared and didn’t have any cleaning products with her. The communication with the office was very difficult as calls kept dropping and they never followed through with housekeeping. All contact with the office stopped after 5:30pm. All bed sheets contained hair, smelled dingy, and there were white stains on the pillow cases. Hair was found inside and outside of sheets and pillow cases. The bathrooms had hair in the shower and around the toilets. The floor was filthy and clearly not mopped before our arrival, our feet tracked all of the dirt. We had waited until our 4pm check-in time and nothing had been cleaned or prepared for our arrival. We spent our first night in Maui washing sheets. Very disappointing. I would not recommend.”
airbnb
AliciaOctober 2026
“Nice property and quiet. Looks like pics. Main bathroom has plumbing issues— tub and sink don’t drain. And toilet runs very loudly every 20 min or so. Owners are not responsive to questions. TV is only usable if you have a Samsung acct. literally no TV or movies without it.”
airbnb
DerekMay 2026
“bugs everywhere. found bugs in bed each night. not worth it. its not 1980 anymore”
airbnb
May 2026
“Had a great stay”
airbnb
May 2026
“We had a lovely stay with our little family, it’s a really beautiful home with a great view! We will visit again!”
airbnb