Manager Review

Vacasa in Hilo, Hawaii

4.39

This is the local review page for Vacasa in Hilo, Hawaii. Amongst managers in Hilo, Vacasa currently ranks 3 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Hilo, or see homeowner reviews of Vacasa on their profile.

Vacasa's guest rating in Hilo, Hawaii of 4.39 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Hilo.

Recent guest reviews

JessicaMay 2026
Great place to stay in Hilo. The best swimming beach in Hilo is right out your backdoor. Beautiful location!
airbnb
JamesApril 2026
AVOID THIS PLACE I've been on Airbnb for over 10 years and stayed at dozens of locations here in Hawaii and also in the mainland. I don't think I've ever left a negative review until now. first, this place is increribly noisy. not just regular traffic noises, but there are homeless people who scream obscenities throughout the day and night right next door. The store next door also has a 24/7 bright security light and a loud robotic voice that periodically says "this area is under constant surveillance" besides this, the hot water doesn't work, or only barely works for about 5 minutes the parking space and washer/dryer were inaccessible due to maintenance for a significant portion of our stay the AC in the bedroom doesn't work well, it's seems old or underpowered. the place is extremely hot ! finally the worst part was the host tried to charge us $600 extra for a broken closet door (literally fell off the hinges the first day) and for a broken foot on the flimsy cheap bed frame
airbnb
RockyApril 2026
Nice layout apartment style setting
airbnb
JennyFebruary 2026
The biggest issue I had was check in. No instructions/code for the lock box were given until 1 hour and 12 mins after my check in time. I had requested an early check in if possible and they stated if possible someone would message me before 4pm. No message came which was ok until 4pm had come and gone and still no check in instructions came. I messaged them multiple times about it and finally at 5:12 they gave me them. I then requested a late check out to make up for the late check in, this was also declined. Definitely a very frustrating experience. The room itself is actually very lovely. Updated bathroom and nice little kitchen with new appliances. The location is remote but within 5-10 min drive of anywhere in Hilo which was nice. There is a lot of nature noises from the frogs but if you use the AC and a white noise machine it will drown it out. Overall I wouldn’t come back strictly because of my experience with the company managing this Airbnb and the lack of communication.
airbnb
MichelleJanuary 2026
Check in was not smooth. I was sent two different code and there were two lock boxes by the door making it confusing. The unit itself was exactly as described and had everything we needed.
airbnb