Manager Review

Coldwell Banker Island Vacations reviews in Hawaii

Coldwell Banker Island Vacations's guest reviews across Hawaii. See homeowner reviews of Coldwell Banker Island Vacations on their profile.

Coldwell Banker Island Vacations's guest rating in Hawaii of 4.75 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Hawaii.

Recent guest reviews

ClaraOctober 2026Waikoloa Village
“The property was gorgeous. Condo was tastefully decorated. Things need to be fixed. Asked for king bed three times and they just pushed the two beds together. Coffee machine but no pot. Broken dishwasher. Was told repairman would come by. It didn’t happen.”
airbnb
DespenaOctober 2026Waikoloa Village
“Pros: 1)Well equipped kitchen 2) Comfortable bed 3)Lots of beach amenities (chairs, boogie boards, etc.) 4)Elevator 5) Location 6)AC & fans worked well 7) Outdoor furniture was fine Cons: 1) Extremely tired 2) Old furniture 3) Tiny tv 4) Heavily stained carpets 5) New microwave and new shower head needed”
airbnb
ChrystolOctober 2026Kapaa
“We really enjoyed our stay at Plantation Hale Suites! The location is fantastic, the grounds are beautiful, and the resort as a whole is wonderful. We would absolutely stay here again, just not in this particular unit. Unfortunately, the unit needs some attention. Although advertised as newly renovated, its condition did not reflect that description. There were moisture issues, including a bathroom leak and warped, soft flooring that was separating and left impressions from furniture. These issues made it difficult to comfortably use portions of the indoor living space. There were also cleanliness and maintenance concerns, including deteriorating cabinetry and evidence of pests. The air conditioning was quite loud, and there was some road noise. Despite these concerns, we had a wonderful time on Kauai and truly enjoyed the resort. Hopefully, these issues will be addressed so future guests can enjoy the unit as much as we enjoyed the location!”
airbnb
MelisaOctober 2026Waimea
“Beautiful and amazing access to beautiful privafe beach, walking trails, restaurants, coffee shop, really perfect. We spent a lot of time on the back porch and balcony and were visited by geckos, wild turkeys, Beautiful birds, discovered fruit trees. Just lovely”
airbnb
KaraOctober 2026Kapaa
“The unit was clean and very functional for two couples. Close to shopping and dining and we appreciated the quiet.”
airbnb

Amongst managers in Hawaii, Coldwell Banker Island Vacations currently ranks 62/105 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Hawaii.