Manager Review

Tybee Cottages reviews in Tybee Island, Georgia

4.73

Tybee Cottages holds a 4.73 guest rating in Tybee Island, Georgia, computed from 290 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 8 of 13 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Tybee Island, or homeowner reviews of Tybee Cottages on their profile.

Tybee Cottages's guest rating in Tybee Island, Georgia of 4.73 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Tybee Island.

Recent guest reviews in Tybee Island

MabryOctober 2026
“This house was beautiful! Quintessential Tybee! Very well furnished/stocked and great location. We loved it.”
airbnb
RebeccaOctober 2026
“Palm Cottage was absolutely adorable! It looked exactly like the pictures and included small details that really lifted the stay (ie. laundry detergent, coffee, soap, shampoo, etc.) It's the little things that make the difference! Location was great and very walkable.”
airbnb
ShelliOctober 2026
“The house is lovely and conveniently located, right near the beach. The bedrooms were clean and well maintained, with plenty of extra toilet paper available. The kitchen was fully stocked with utensils, and the pantry included a great selection of appliances, paper towels, and laundry detergent. There was one beach chair in the garage, but otherwise, you’ll need to bring or rent beach chairs, beach towels, and an umbrella, so it’s good to know that ahead of time. We had one issue during our stay, but the hosts addressed it immediately. They were very responsive and helpful whenever we had questions. A few essentials, such as extra towels, were not provided, but overall, we had a very pleasant stay. There is also a cabinet in the living room on the kitchen level filled with games and books, which was a nice touch.”
airbnb
IsisSeptember 2026
“It was a nice place. It was a little dusty. We had a maintenance man show up and we didn’t know about it. The rooms were comfortable. The upstairs was a little hot compared to the mid level. The pool wasn’t super clean but got cleaned afterwards. The outside patio where the pool is could use some help because there were fake nails and hair bands thrown around and it was messy. The house was comfortable for the 8 of use and the dining room was great. Prepping and cutting knives were not sharp so I would suggest to bring your own if you can but the kitchen did have most of what was needed.”
airbnb
KrisAugust 2026
“The location is very convenient. The house can definitely stand some work the yard/out door furniture was not the same as posted was not useable so my granddaughter wasn’t able to play outside due to upkeep. The floor in the hallway is settling about 2inches. If my mother had made the trip she would have had a hard time with it. The first night I was turning down the bed for my daughter and son and a brown recluse spider and at me I have photos. The water was lukewarm and the master shower head/handle needs to be replaced. There needs to be a closed cabinet for the cards/games and movies not very toddler friendly at all. Could really use a split unit for the porch area half the house was freezing while the other 1/2 was warm. On day 3 I removed the sheet from the master bed to find nasty yellow stains. Needles to say I did not remove any of the others.I called and spoke with Amy she was to call me back still waiting. I took before and after photos for reference of our stay.”
airbnb