Manager Review

Resort Rentals reviews in Treasure Island, Florida

4.65

Resort Rentals holds a 4.65 guest rating in Treasure Island, Florida, computed from 2,328 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 10 of 15 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Treasure Island, or homeowner reviews of Resort Rentals on their profile.

Resort Rentals's guest rating in Treasure Island, Florida of 4.65 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Treasure Island.

Recent guest reviews in Treasure Island

RebeccaOctober 2026
“The house was gorgeous and in a perfect location. We were right on the beach & a 20 min uber to downtown St Pete! 13 of my girlfriends celebrated my sisters bach and had a blast. There were beach bars a half mile away, yet we were so secluded and safe. I gave this listing 3 stars for a few reasons. I booked our reservation for 13, & when we arrived to the house and there was 1 roll of paper towel, 1 garbage bag, & bathrooms didn’t have extra toilet paper. I reached out to the host, & they told me there should be a “care package”, when I said we didn’t find out they didn’t respond. The front door was super hard to open/close and it was an issue the entire time. The third floor bedrooms had small ants. The downstairs bathroom door handle falls right off. The worst part was it was a beach house with no beach towels/no extra towels in general. The WiFi also stopped working. This was a beautiful house amazing for my sisters bach, however there were things that can definitely improve.”
airbnb
BrianSeptember 2026
“The good news about this rental is the location. It's VERY close to a beautiful beach. Fun times at Caddy's and the Tiki all around. The house itself was pretty clean and pretty well equipped. Space is a little tight but the rooftop is also nice. The bad news is that the pool was completely unusable for the entire time we were there. The pool was a shade of green usually reserved for a sports drink. The outdoor area had also not been touched is some time as there were leaves and debris all over. This property is run by a rental company, not a home owner. The pool man didn't arrive until 1.5 days after we arrived. Wrote a DO NOT SWIM notice after treating the pool. He never returned on Monday to let us know if it was swimmable. We did receive a partial refund but it was small in comparison to the loss of the pool. The rental company did reach out about switching pool company services. Hopefully someone else will have a better experience than we did.”
airbnb
SamanthaSeptember 2026
“We really liked our stay here! Being right across the street from the beach and caddy’s was a huge plus! The place needs some upgrading but it was clean and easy to access. My only downside was that it didn’t have a blow dryer. I have never stayed in a place on vacation (hotel, Airbnb, etc) that didn’t have one. This made getting ready for our activities annoying because I had to plan it around air drying my hair after a shower. I think it would be best if the owner buys one for the unit.”
airbnb
ShannonSeptember 2026
“Great location getting to fish off the dock and still walk to the beach. Cabana rentals are super expensive so don’t bother. Only one parking spot and guest spots are hard to get especially if it was full, it was pretty empty most of our stay and it was still rough. The pans need to be replaced badly if you plan on cooking there it’s doable but not easy. It’s definitely not a fully stocked kitchen. The WiFi worked but there is no password so we couldn’t connect our owlet baby monitor. No bathtub either but we knew that going in and made due. We had to buy trash bags, salt and pepper and seasoning, dish washer pods, toilet paper and paper towels so that was weird. Usually there is enough for the stay at most places we have rented. You absolutely cannot check in until 4 on the dot so that was hard with a baby but the staff there is super friendly. A lot of pros and cons. But overall a good stay.”
airbnb
May 2026
“Spacious, updated unit with a gulf view. Location was great and plenty of room for a family of 5.”
airbnb