Manager Review

First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals in St. Augustine, Florida

4.78

This is the local review page for First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals in St. Augustine, Florida. Amongst managers in St. Augustine, First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals currently ranks 17 of 34 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in St. Augustine, or see homeowner reviews of First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals on their profile.

First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals's guest rating in St. Augustine, Florida of 4.78 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in St. Augustine.

Recent guest reviews

AngieAugust 2026
We had a great stay! The condo was clean, beautifully decorated, and right on the beach. It had helpful kitchen basics, easy check-in, and convenient parking. We loved the nice gated pool with plenty of seating. Plus, it was less than five minutes from the amphitheater, which was perfect for our weekend trip. Highly recommend!
airbnb
SaidyAugust 2026
We come to the area every year and this was our first time staying in this home. The house was fine but was extremely hot — the front door had no seal so air was coming straight through and there were no curtains on the front windows to block the sun. The second bedroom also had two twin beds not a queen as listed. Our kids really enjoyed the outside area but it was extremely dangerous. The stairs are wobbly and have screws popping up in multiple spots. Not to mention the wood entry way completely fell off last night. Thankfully no one got hurt. The house definitely needs some attention and for that reason we would not return.
airbnb
YukiJuly 2026
Unfortunately, we had a very disappointing stay. The home had numerous cleanliness and maintenance problems, including live and dead ants, spiders, cobwebs, bugs in the sinks, and dead roaches on the patio. There was also a strong bug spray odor throughout the home. The shower had what appeared to be black mold, and there was also mold in the HVAC vents. The drain was clogged with hair, there was hair on the bathroom faucet, and the bed sheets were stained. We also noticed gaps in the walls and flooring, broken blinds, and smoke detectors that were not functioning. Due to the combination of cleanliness, maintenance, and safety concerns, we checked out the next morning. We requested a refund based on the condition of the property, but the host declined. We strongly advise against booking this property.
airbnb
AlexJuly 2026
Very nice place, walkable to beach, complex was nice and peaceful. Appreciate the stay
airbnb
RosandreaJuly 2026
Great view of ocean but in desperate need of an upgrade in deep cleaning. In addition, Marty is trying to blackmail me by saying that he won’t post negative things about me if I don’t post about him. I have the evidence of that communication.
airbnb