Manager Review

First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals in St. Augustine, Florida

4.76

This is the local review page for First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals in St. Augustine, Florida. Amongst managers in St. Augustine, First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals currently ranks 10 of 21 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in St. Augustine, or see homeowner reviews of First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals on their profile.

First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals's guest rating in St. Augustine, Florida of 4.76 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in St. Augustine.

Recent guest reviews

Kelsey LeighannMay 2026
“Loved the stay! Great condo that looked just like the pictures! Highly recommend.”
airbnb
StephenMay 2026
“Great location. Every thing you need for a stay at the beach.”
airbnb
May 2026
“The location was amazing, many locally owned businesses. We enjoyed the Sunrise Brew Coffee shop nearby, the coffee was great and the food was tasty. The location to the beach was phenomenal, we walked each day. The condo itself was a little outdated but definitely had everything we needed for a 4-5 nights stay. The biggest issue we had was the shower situation. We had 2 showers but only could run the water in one at a time making showers after a day at the beach a bit challenging. The pool was nice, warm and plenty of seating. Overall, we would stay here again for the convenience and the owner was kind and very responsive.”
airbnb
May 2026
“We had a great time overall at Marty’s place. It was super comfortable, well set up, and had everything we needed. The coffee maker broke during our stay and we received a replacement the next day. We recommend this place for anyone who wants to get a quiet getaway.”
airbnb
RoseMay 2026
“Celebrated a memorial weekend with a girls trip and enjoyed every bit of our stay. We loved it!”
airbnb