Manager Review

AvantStay reviews in St. Augustine, Florida

4.72

AvantStay holds a 4.72 guest rating in St. Augustine, Florida, computed from 187 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 19 of 28 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in St. Augustine, or homeowner reviews of AvantStay on their profile.

AvantStay's guest rating in St. Augustine, Florida of 4.72 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in St. Augustine.

Recent guest reviews in St. Augustine

JaySeptember 2026
“House is nice and large. Furnishings are Ikea and memory foam. Argued with AvantStay because we brought a small, 4x8' trailer for our luggage. They insisted it was not allowed to be parked at house, threatened that it could be towed or we could be fined. They sent their own policy which specifically states that boats and RVs are not allowed, nothing about a small trailer. They insisted trailers weren't permitted to be parked in neighborhood even after I provided 4 photos of houses on the same, short road that had boats and trailers. Very frustrating and stressful. A few outlets didn't work. Pool was dirty upon arrival and was never cleaned despite requesting and being told it would be. Pool table is almost useless, cues were just plastic and didn't work well. Grass was very long upon arrival, that did get fixed upon notifying AvantStay. I'll avoid management companies in the future when booking and look for owners.”
airbnb
AndersonSeptember 2026
“Solid place to stay with a big group. Would recommend”
airbnb
AshtonSeptember 2026
“The houses were beautiful and comfortable for our stay. However, be forewarned there is a neighbor who makes constant complaints to the owners about every small thing. There was also a neighbor who felt it appropriate to verbally assault my mother while outside of the house regarding parking during my son's birthday party. The amenities were very nice and the management company was communicative. However, in their efforts to address the complaints from the neighbor (only 1 person) they blew up my phone constantly over the last 2 days of our stay and even threatened to evict us from the house. Might I add, we have never had any negative reviews or ever been treated this way at any other airbnb.”
airbnb
ChristianAugust 2026
“We loved our house and vacation in St. Augustine! The beach was very close, and the pool was great for our kids. I would recommend this house for anyone looking to visit St. Augustine. Thank you!”
airbnb
LaurenAugust 2026
“Great spot for the beach and a few local restaurants”
airbnb