Manager Review

Great Stay Homes in Osprey, Florida

4.43

This is the local review page for Great Stay Homes in Osprey, Florida. Amongst managers in Osprey, Great Stay Homes currently ranks 2 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Osprey, or see homeowner reviews of Great Stay Homes on their profile.

Great Stay Homes's guest rating in Osprey, Florida of 4.43 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Osprey.

Recent guest reviews

PaulMarch 2026
“The home was great but the yard was unkept and the pool had constant debris in it. If the yard was better managed the pool would be cleaner. We had to call for yard maintenance multiple times and had to purchase home goods missing from the house. Otherwise the house was fine and we had a great time in Florida.”
airbnb
TodJanuary 2026
“Even though there is a hot tub in the pictures there isn’t one at the house.Unfortunately for our grandkids.”
airbnb
November 2025
“We really enjoyed the home, we were able to spread out and bring out dogs (which was a plus). Having the heated pool was great! We spent Thanksgiving at the house. Overall, it went great. We enjoyed beach (casey key), dog walks, restaurants and bars (Casey Key Fish house is great). Thank you for being responsive to all of our requests.”
airbnb
December 2024
“It appears the management company wasn't worried about ensuring the home was ready for guests. It was clean but there were several issues with the house, including a broken bed frame and bedroom door knob. we noticed the management company who sent someone out the next day. We reported other issues such as the empty propane tank on the grill and the hot tub that wouldn't heat up. They acknowledged the issues and then did nothing about it. this was also the 1st place we've stayed in (of several) that did not have any spices or other basic cooking supplies such as oil. I would not recommend any properties managed by this company.”
airbnb
July 2023
“We thoroughly enjoyed our stay! The house was perfect for our crew of 4 adults and 4 kids! 10/10- would recommend!!!”
airbnb