Manager Review

Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys in Marathon, Florida

4.76

This is the local review page for Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys in Marathon, Florida. Amongst managers in Marathon, Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys currently ranks 5 of 8 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Marathon, or see homeowner reviews of Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys on their profile.

Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys's guest rating in Marathon, Florida of 4.76 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Marathon.

Recent guest reviews

May 2026
I truly think that the only thing that was not explained is that you have to go through the master bedroom to get to the bunk room and the garage with the washer and dryer. Other than that it was fantastic! Seen lots of fish in the canal, felt safe in the neighborhood and had plenty of room to hang out inside or out with 8 people. I would highly recommend this stay to anyone.
airbnb
May 2026
This place could be excellent if cleaning issues are addressed. Cornhole game in the side yard is rotted and needs replaced. Rental company is responsive. Great location for accessing local restaurants, shops, and boat rentals. Peaceful, serene neighborhood.
airbnb
TaraMay 2026
Very disappointed. Home was beautiful, easy to find, & convenient. BUT (1) The wall between the living room & bedroom didn’t go up to the ceiling so there was zero privacy. (2) The shower water was pure cold & their response time was TERRIBLE! Sent a message through Airbnb at 8:39am but no response at all, so I sent a text the NEXT evening at 5:15pm (33 hours later!). During that text conversation, every single message started with “Hi (my name)” even messages that were moments apart, making me concerned it was AI, so I asked and got the following: “Previous responses are not AI. They are an assist team we use for prompt responses to guests. They escalate issues out of their control to our team and we provide solutions.” which seemed nebulous, so I reworded it and asked specifically if it was human. The response: “Wtf ...is that human enough?” At that point I decided I will never again rent a home owned by Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys.
airbnb
May 2026
I absolutely loved this home. It’s a beautiful home and has plenty of space for family or friends. This house is also child friendly there is a swimming pool and it is right on the canal. The canal is full of huge tarpon, which was really nice to be able to see every day. The Host was very attentive and was easy to communicate with.
airbnb
May 2026
Our stay was absolutely wonderful. We stayed for 2 weeks with 4 small children and this place felt like paradise for all of us. From the pool, to the kayaks/paddle boards, to card games overlooking the canal, it was wonderful in every way. The hosts were very responsive and answered any questions in a timely manner. There was ample space for a family of 6. The kitchen met our needs. The plus of having the high chair/pac n play made travel easier. We would definitely return!
airbnb