Manager Review

Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys in Key Colony Beach, Florida

4.76

This is the local review page for Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys in Key Colony Beach, Florida. Amongst managers in Key Colony Beach, Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys currently ranks 2 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Key Colony Beach, or see homeowner reviews of Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys on their profile.

Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys's guest rating in Key Colony Beach, Florida of 4.76 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Key Colony Beach.

Recent guest reviews

MeganMay 2026
We had a great stay! The place was exactly as the listing said and pictures were accurate. The pool was great and the view was beautiful! This is very close to several places to eat, grocery shop and even the dollar store! The neighborhood is peaceful and feels very safe. We truly enjoyed our stay.
airbnb
RobinMay 2026
Very nice and easy. Would be nice to have extra things like bikes fishing poles etc for added fun. But overall was a good stay.
airbnb
JustinMay 2026
Although the location and overall home were both very nice there were some concerning maintenance issues. The left gate would hardly open even with 2 larger than average men. This was a huge inconvenience for the fact we had 3 guest and needed to use both driveways . The guest bathroom faucet was about to fall off . The hammock broke when my wife sat in due to the old dry rotted straps securing it to the tree. Aside from the lack of general upkeep there was a nosey neighbor that kept staring in house and went as far as walking in the empty lot next door to look over the gate . Lastly the pool guy showed up unexpectedly when we were all hanging out by the pool to clean it and basically made it un usable for a hour or two . You would think this could be done in between stays
airbnb
NathenApril 2026
Would rent there again. Relaxing vibe for sure.
airbnb
Holly And PilarApril 2026
I was supposed to receive check in instructions 2 weeks prior. No communication at all. Day of arrival, I had to reach out to them to get code to get in the house. Property manager said I would receive it at 3:45. Nothing received. I had to contact property owner again for the code. Property owner did not even know the code to get the key for the house, or that it did not have a keypad to get in. Washer was broken, kitchen sink was leaking-floor was a puddle, both doors don't latch and we found a large blood stain on one of the mattresses. Had to spend 3 days of our vacation waiting for maintenence. Canceled plans because of it. We rented thru Airbnb at this same house when it was listed by the owners. We had a phenomenal experience then and house was well taken care of. But this time, was horrible. Property manager slow to respond and when asked 4 different times for a partial refund never gets back to me.
airbnb