The Key to The Keys in Key Colony Beach, Florida
4.90This is the local review page for The Key to The Keys in Key Colony Beach, Florida. Amongst managers in Key Colony Beach, The Key to The Keys currently ranks 4 of 9 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Key Colony Beach, or see homeowner reviews of The Key to The Keys on their profile.
Recent guest reviews
·Maxine·August 2026
“Dear Mark & Lisa, Thank you once again for letting us stay in your beautiful condo! After a busy and hectic schedule at Universal Orlando, our family of three couldn’t have picked a better place to relax and chill out for 11 nights. The condo was incredibly well-stocked and had absolutely everything we could have asked for. Our son Gabriel loves to fish and he was over the moon about having our own private pier. He couldn't believe his luck catching a Nurse Shark, Tarpons, Snapper, and Stingrays right outside! We also loved exploring Marathon and the surrounding Florida Keys. Your location made it so easy to visit Horseshoe Beach, Sombrero Beach, Bahia Honda State Park, Pigeon Key, and take the Lady Marathon Boat Trip. We highly recommend your place to anyone looking to stay in Marathon. In fact, we are already planning our next big trip back here next year! Best wishes, Christian, Maxine and Gabriel”airbnb
·Mike·August 2026
“The condo was great and lived up to expectations from the photos and description. Yuni was helpful whenever we had an inquiry. The location is in a peaceful part of Key Colony Beach. The access to the Cabana Club was a plus and allowed us options as to two different types of pool experiences. Our only disappointment was that the sargassum on the beach on the property was not raked during our week stay. As we were leaving on Saturday morning, the tractor appeared on the property for the first time. We were fortunate that the smell was not overwhelming during our stay. Access to local restaurants was great and there are a variety of things to do in Marathon Key and surrounding area.”airbnb
·Martin J·July 2026
“Our stay at Finer Things in Key Colony beach was wonderful. The host was fantastic and we loved the condo. I would be mindful, having never gone to the Florida Keys about the Sargassum in the water and on the beach. We were not able to use the beach at all, however that was mother nature's fault not our host. It also typically is not that heavy. The view and the pool were still great, and my older boys fished from the pier and caught nurse sharks. They also saw manatees and pelicans. Our host gave us excellent alternative beach recommendations which we used instead. We also visited Sombrero beach which was very nice and right in town. I would highly recommend Horseshoe beach and Veteran's memorial beach both about a 25 minute drive away across the 7 mile bridge. There are also 2 great restaurants very close, Sparky's landing and Havana Jack's. Sunset beach is also a very nice spot right in Key Colony. You can't swim there, but it's a beautiful place to enjoy the sunset on the ocean.”airbnb
·Jodie·July 2026
“We absolutely loved this condo. It is nestled in Sea Colony Beach, which has a sweet small town feel. The unit is beautiful and Yumi responded quickly when we reached out. The only negative of the whole week, which could not be controlled by the owners was the sargassum that was covering the beach. We were upset about it when we first arrived, but the week ended up being amazing anyway. We used the pool quite a bit and worked around it by going to one of the sand bars by boat and renting jet skis. There were several other beaches like Bahia Honda that had not been affected by the sargassum. We also spent a day at Dry Tortugas National Park, which we HIGHLY recommend. The whole family agreed that we would love to go back to Marathon and if we do, we will definitely see about staying on the same property.”airbnb
·Mandy·July 2026
“We had a great vacation here! The setting was beautiful and the location was perfect and centrally located for exploring the Keys. The space was clean and tidy and we were very comfortable the whole stay. Our hosts provided clear instructions and were very responsive whenever we had a question. We would definitely recommend this amazing rental if you’re visiting the gorgeous Florida Keys!”airbnb