Manager Review

Amelia Island Vacations reviews in Fernandina Beach, Florida

4.65

Amelia Island Vacations holds a 4.65 guest rating in Fernandina Beach, Florida, computed from 1,303 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 10 of 12 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Fernandina Beach, or homeowner reviews of Amelia Island Vacations on their profile.

Amelia Island Vacations's guest rating in Fernandina Beach, Florida of 4.65 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Fernandina Beach.

Recent guest reviews in Fernandina Beach

AmySeptember 2026
“Very nice close walking distance to beach. Living room furniture could use updating, is not the furniture in photos for the unit. Windows/ Porch doors need updating. Nice kitchen.”
airbnb
BethAugust 2026
“The location was great. It was an easy walk to the pool and the beach. The condo was well equipped with kitchen items and had plenty of space. The only issue was the place smelled of urine.”
airbnb
HaleyAugust 2026
“We had a great stay here! It was peaceful and close to the beach. We really enjoyed going to the beach each evening and watching the sunset. The house was clean and comfortable, other than the dishes we had to clean to use. I also wish they had changed the water filter (it was overdue) because the tap water on the island does not taste good. The elevator did periodically quit working on us, and we found the written check-in instructions a little confusing. I would also recommend asking for the contract up front so you can ensure that it matches the rules on the listing. Last, $50/hr for early checkin/late check out feels criminal and really cut into our last day. Though not a detractor, it should be noted that this Airbnb is on the beautiful beach side of the island and it is not in walking distance to the bustling historic downtown marina-side.”
airbnb
CrayAugust 2026
“presented these suggestions to the hosts, Carol and Richard Stephens, but received no response. For the convenience and safety of future guests, I do hope they’re interested in considering them. A few are relatively minor; others concerning guest safety are not. 1) Of paramount importance is the dangerous exit from the driveway onto South Fletcher. During the day Fletcher carries significant traffic. Many vehicles, including construction trucks hauling trailers, use this road. Many don’t obey the speed limit. The house has a wall with a hedge above that, together, obstruct the sight line looking south. (I noticed that, when in the southbound lane, one of the owners pulled onto the berm to allow traffic to clear before he backed into the drive crossing both lanes, a dangerous maneuver made to enable safer exit when leaving.) Before pulling onto Fletcher, a driver must nose his/her vehicle into the northbound lane to see oncoming traffic. Again, a very dangerous maneuver. The”
airbnb
TeraJuly 2026
“We came to Amelia Island and the Fernandina Beach area to celebrate my sister‘s 50th birthday. We had 10 girls total and mainly just needed the house for a place to sleep. Thankfully, we only had eight girls on Friday night because on Saturday night when everyone was there, we did not have enough space for everyone to sleep. The trundle bed was broken and there was not enough space for two people to sleep on the couch. One of our ladies ended up leaving. There are no curtains in the living room or the master bedroom so when the sun comes up in the morning the entire place gets blazing hot. The air conditioner was having a very tough time keeping up. The couches in the living room were dirty. There was a bad smell coming from some of the kitchen cabinets. They only left us one single trash bag that was in the trash container in the kitchen, and we also only had two dishwasher pods. Overall, I would say the description of this place online is not accurate it definitely does not sleep 10!”
airbnb