Manager Review

American Realty of Captiva reviews in Captiva, Florida

4.76

American Realty of Captiva holds a 4.76 guest rating in Captiva, Florida, computed from 198 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 5 of 9 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Captiva, or homeowner reviews of American Realty of Captiva on their profile.

American Realty of Captiva's guest rating in Captiva, Florida of 4.76 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Captiva.

Recent guest reviews in Captiva

LindaOctober 2026
“We loved the direct access to the beach. The grandkids loved the pool. The guest house worked great with the new grandbaby napping at different times than the other kids. This property needed some TLC, a leak in the living room ceiling, black mold on master toilet ceiling, broken step at pool and spa malfunctioned at least 4 times while we were there which disabled the filter for the pool the grandkids were playing in. Not the level of maintenance for the house we are accustomed to at this price range. Neighbor construction was noisy. No House User Manual or local recommendations. The maintenance people answered our calls promptly so missed 2 nights of hot tub for the adults. American Realty gave us a 3 hour late check out, nice. Understand why October is off season in Florida - humidity and No See Um bugs made outdoor activities unpleasant. Loved Ding Darling Nature Preserve (driving). Did a kayak outing and everyone loved it but ended up with no less than 50 bites per limb!!”
airbnb
GraceOctober 2026
“Super nice house!”
airbnb
JustinSeptember 2026
“Our 2 families loved the property. The location was great, the amenities were great. The place was very clean and welcoming”
airbnb
WinstonSeptember 2026
“Beautiful home, quiet neighborhood, and walking distance to beach and restaurants! We had a great stay.”
airbnb
SailySeptember 2026
“Amazing place and good location”
airbnb