Manager Review

American Realty of Captiva

American Realty of Captiva's guest rating of 4.76 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review American Realty of Captiva.

Recent guest reviews

CathyAugust 2026Captiva, Florida
Family enjoyed staying for five days. Close proximity to the beach and having the pool was wonderful for the kids.
airbnb
KarenAugust 2026Captiva, Florida
As much as I don’t want to write this review because then everyone will know about this amazing place I just have to. The location to the beach, food, shopping etc is unbeatable. The house is beautiful and spacious. The pool and outdoor shower were awesome! We will definitely be renting from here again!
airbnb
Maria FernandaAugust 2026Captiva, Florida
We had a wonderful stay! The house was very peaceful, private, and cozy, which made it the perfect place to relax. The views were absolutely beautiful, and we really enjoyed the calm atmosphere throughout our stay. Everything felt comfortable and welcoming. We would definitely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a quiet and relaxing getaway!
airbnb
BeckyAugust 2026Captiva, Florida
Almost Heaven was even better than imagined. The house had so much space and the amenities were great. Inside and outside there was always enough seating for everyone in our group. We loved reading on the patio, eating lunch by the pool, and playing on the little putting green. We enjoyed a completely empty beach, beautiful sunsets, and easy walks to restaurants. We would definitely stay here again if we find ourselves back in Captiva.
airbnb
MistyAugust 2026Captiva, Florida
No keys for access so we had to walk around the house every time to get in. Towel bars falling out of the wall. Burned out light bulbs. Cabinet glass fell out onto my son. Hot tub randomly drains multiple times per day. Ants all of the kitchen counter. Hardly any seashells here on the beach. For what we paid to stay here this place is not worth it.
airbnb
FernandoAugust 2026Captiva, Florida
Had a great stay. Great location and house - will consider going back soon. Suggestion: 1. Inform guests that trash will be picked up on Wednesdays AND that the bins must be placed on the street. We did not know and therefore, trash was not picked up. Needs to be clearer to avoid confusion.
airbnb
DanielleAugust 2026Captiva, Florida
We had a great time at Almost Heaven. Awesome location and worked great for our families! Loved Captiva and being able to walk to the beach, shops and restaurants!
airbnb
DougAugust 2026Captiva, Florida
House was amazing. Loved the bunk beds & pool. So close to the ocean. We really enjoyed our stay!
airbnb
ChristinaJuly 2026Captiva, Florida
Great place for a family vacation. This was our favorite Captiva rental so far. Each bedroom was comfortable and had its own bathroom for plenty of space and privacy. The kitchen and living room and pool deck offered nice areas for hanging out together. We lived the pool and hot tub for afternoon cool downs. The house was well stocked with basic supplies as well as plenty of towels and beach gear. The location is an easy walk to the beach, shops, restaurants, Jensen’s Marina, and the Island Store. We will definitely book again for our next trip!
airbnb
BettyJuly 2026Captiva, Florida
Beautiful house and pool, great location. Rated only good because there was a leak in the master bedroom, and for the price there were limited supplies (paper towels, washer soap, etc.) and explanations. The TV was very hard to work. American Realty never responded about the leak and took a day to respond to another issue.
airbnb

Local Rankings