Manager Review

American Realty of Captiva

American Realty of Captiva's guest rating of 4.76 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review American Realty of Captiva.

Recent guest reviews

GraceOctober 2026Captiva, Florida
“Super nice house!”
airbnb
WinstonSeptember 2026Captiva, Florida
“Beautiful home, quiet neighborhood, and walking distance to beach and restaurants! We had a great stay.”
airbnb
JustinSeptember 2026Captiva, Florida
“Our 2 families loved the property. The location was great, the amenities were great. The place was very clean and welcoming”
airbnb
SailySeptember 2026Captiva, Florida
“Amazing place and good location”
airbnb
MarienSeptember 2026Captiva, Florida
“Absolutely loved this house, best one yet, definitely staying here again 🥰”
airbnb
AmberSeptember 2026Captiva, Florida
“The location of this home is hard to beat! It’s on a quiet street just a short walk to the beach, with great restaurants, coffee, and ice cream nearby. The home itself is a bit dated and could use some updating and additional attention in a few areas, particularly the bathrooms. There were also some ant control measures throughout the home that weren’t ideal when traveling with a toddler. We understand that bugs and moisture can be more common when staying so close to the beach. Overall, the location is definitely the highlight and made for a very convenient stay.”
airbnb
JudySeptember 2026Captiva, Florida
“The house was perfect for our family. Great location and lots of privacy.”
airbnb
EmilySeptember 2026Captiva, Florida
“We had an amazing, multi-generational family vacation! Everyone had plenty of space to be together or get some privacy. We spent the whole trip between our beach area and the house. Would definitely recommend!”
airbnb
MistyAugust 2026Captiva, Florida
“No keys for access so we had to walk around the house every time to get in. Towel bars falling out of the wall. Burned out light bulbs. Cabinet glass fell out onto my son. Hot tub randomly drains multiple times per day. Ants all of the kitchen counter. Hardly any seashells here on the beach. For what we paid to stay here this place is not worth it.”
airbnb
BettyJuly 2026Captiva, Florida
“Beautiful house and pool, great location. Rated only good because there was a leak in the master bedroom, and for the price there were limited supplies (paper towels, washer soap, etc.) and explanations. The TV was very hard to work. American Realty never responded about the leak and took a day to respond to another issue.”
airbnb

Local Rankings