Manager Review

1st Choice Properties in Selbyville, Delaware

4.86

This is the local review page for 1st Choice Properties in Selbyville, Delaware. Amongst managers in Selbyville, 1st Choice Properties currently ranks 5 of 11 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Selbyville, or see homeowner reviews of 1st Choice Properties on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

SandyAugust 2026
GREAT rental. Everything nearly brand-new. Communication was good. Missing towels delivered in 30 mins; reported TP holders bent. Comfy beds & couch. Everything very clean. Spacious garage. Many beach items provided. Cleaning supplies plentiful. Nice neighborhood, brand-new community of Bay Knolls. Area felt safe. Friendly neighbors. Active construction in the area; this unit was far enough from noise. Pool clean, not heavily used. Close to necessities. Farm market nearby. Easy drive to Fenwick. Great place to spend a rainy afternoon inside. Also, a shuffleboard table! If you don’t know how to play, I highly recommend! Suggestions: Add towel hooks/bars. No good place to hang wet towels/bathing suits. Safety bars for toilets/showers. 4pm check-in & office close at 5pm doesn’t allow much room for travel delays & reporting issues. Recommend either allowing earlier check-in, or manning office phones later than 5 p.m. instead of relying on voicemail. They did respond to texts quickly.
airbnb
GaryAugust 2026
Whenever we stay at an Airbnb, I always ask myself, “would you stay here again?” Overwhelmingly YES! Probably the best rental we’ve stayed at. Such a well stocked kitchen! Plenty of furniture and space. Easy access to the pool and fitness room. A short, nice, one mile walk to the Daybreak Cafe which was fabulous.
airbnb
ZaireAugust 2026
We had a wonderful stay! The place was exactly as described—clean, comfortable, and thoughtfully decorated. Everything we needed was provided, and the location was convenient and peaceful. The host was friendly, responsive, and made the entire check-in and check-out process easy. We truly felt at home and appreciated all the little touches that made our stay special. I would happily stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a great Airbnb experience.
airbnb
ErnestineAugust 2026
The property was as described and was in the perfect location the communication was in a professional wav and very quick to respond
airbnb
WilliamAugust 2026
Wonderful property. It was clean, well stocked, and close to everything we needed. The views overlooking Little Assawoman Bay and the morning sunrises were beautiful. Our family had a great time.
airbnb