Manager Review

Second Home Vacation Rentals reviews in Fairplay, Colorado

4.77

Second Home Vacation Rentals holds a 4.77 guest rating in Fairplay, Colorado, computed from 1,651 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 2 of 3 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Fairplay, or homeowner reviews of Second Home Vacation Rentals on their profile.

Second Home Vacation Rentals's guest rating in Fairplay, Colorado of 4.77 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Fairplay.

Recent guest reviews in Fairplay

JeffSeptember 2026
“Great location in close proximity to FairPlay. Private and cozy.”
airbnb
LauraSeptember 2026
“Beautiful, secluded cabin with aspens right off the deck. Road was drivable in a minivan. One of the downstairs bedrooms gets the full brunt of the morning sun, so maybe don't put a kid in there. My family and I really enjoyed our stay here!”
airbnb
ColinAugust 2026
“Rough all the way around. The house is up a very bumpy dirt road that will take at least 30 minutes to traverse every single time. I drive a pretty new lifted jeep and this road was TERRIBLE even with dual fox shocks and 35 inch tires. The nearest store is located in fairplay and has a very limited selection at an an unbelievable markup. Most of the windows do not work and the ones that do have their views obstructed by various warning and labels from the host. I stayed for 2 weeks, the WiFi did not work a single time. I reached out to the host half way through our trip to find out about getting this fixed and they said they’d reach out to the owners but that was the last I heard. I also did not have above 1 bar of cell service at any point in this cabin. The combo of no WiFi and no cell service makes it difficult to plan activities, grocery shop, and enjoy the trip. Additionally there were an ungodly amount of spiders in the property and the beds are hard. Overall would not recommend”
airbnb
AmieAugust 2026
“this house is very nice. quiet. peaceful.”
airbnb
DonnaAugust 2026
“Easy to find and convenient location off the highway. We brought 6 guests and had adequate space for everyone. Communication with host was easy. Having access to the garage was nice for storing gear. Neighborhood is a bit run down and there is no outdoor space to enjoy. There is some noise from the tenants on the other side of the townhouse. This place really needs some updates. If improvements were made it could be a fantastic spot. Instead it reminded us of a cheap motel room with dingy furnishings and linens, stains on both the carpet and shower curtains, and blinds in the bedrooms that are hard to manage. Even my teens complained about how uncomfortable the beds were. Adding room darkening blinds would be really beneficial to keep that bright morning light out. We asked for a later checkout time and host Communicated only 15 minutes grace could be given without a $50 fee. Apparently you have to arrange this in advance and was told this is in the rental agreement that you sign 🙄”
airbnb