Manager Review

Agate Bay Realty reviews in Carnelian Bay, California

4.71

Agate Bay Realty holds a 4.71 guest rating in Carnelian Bay, California, computed from 2,694 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 10 of 14 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Carnelian Bay, or homeowner reviews of Agate Bay Realty on their profile.

Agate Bay Realty's guest rating in Carnelian Bay, California of 4.71 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Carnelian Bay.

Recent guest reviews in Carnelian Bay

HarukaSeptember 2026
“Great location. Spacious room, and it was perfect for me, my husband and my parents. The BBQ was useful! We enjoyed the fireplace. But first thing we noticed was hair on the bathroom floor, and also dirty dishes in the cabinets. Their house keeping can definitely get improved.”
airbnb
SkySeptember 2026
“There are 2 bathrooms on the main floor w 1 bedroom. There are 2 bedrooms on floor 2 with only 1 bathroom. I had to go up & down the stairs a lot to use the bathroom. This wasn't clear on listing. Beautuful home, lots of spaces to hang out. Multiple tv's. Buy your own ice, ice maker didnt work in fridge.”
airbnb
EdwardAugust 2026
“This house is outstanding. We were only 3 + a small dog, but this place can easily accommodate like 10 people. There were bikes, a game room, paddle boards, all of the things a sort of generic Tahoe airbnb would have. It was absolutely what we were looking for. The location is pretty good too: a restaurant/7-Eleven/lake within walking distance. Couldn't ask for more on the house. As for the management company: 1. They force you to use a 3P website to see the house manual/check-out instructions/inform you about things like an electric bear fence that might shock you and your dog at 7 am like it did us. Airbnb already has a place in the app for instructions; Do not force me to go to a 3P site and agree to their terms just to see basic info. 2. There was an 8hr blackout during the stay and management didn't say anything for a while and the house had no emergency supplies. Plus, no cell service, so we were in the dark in more ways than one. Please get a plan for these situations. Not cool”
airbnb
JeremyAugust 2026
“Loved the property. One of the best represented airbnbs I’ve ever been to. Great experience. Host was a little rude but after this review I am sure it will help future guests. Thanks!”
airbnb
NeysaAugust 2026
“We appreciated the safe and quiet location and really enjoyed our weekend. Thank you!”
airbnb