Manager Review

Agate Bay Realty in Carnelian Bay, California

4.70

This is the local review page for Agate Bay Realty in Carnelian Bay, California. Amongst managers in Carnelian Bay, Agate Bay Realty currently ranks 10 of 14 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Carnelian Bay, or see homeowner reviews of Agate Bay Realty on their profile.

Agate Bay Realty's guest rating in Carnelian Bay, California of 4.70 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Carnelian Bay.

Recent guest reviews

NeysaAugust 2026
We appreciated the safe and quiet location and really enjoyed our weekend. Thank you!
airbnb
SaraAugust 2026
Great location! Just a 10 min walk down to a dog-friendly beach and coffee shop. The kitchen was very well appointed with gadgets, and we thoroughly enjoyed breakfasts and dinners on the back deck. We had a great family vacation!
airbnb
ValeriaAugust 2026
No A/C. Gets hot at night; we stayed in the beginning of August. The sheets were saturated in a fabric softener smell. We had to put our clothes on the pillows to sleep— it was such an intense smell. We left the windows open during the day to run to the store. It was so hot. I got a message asking to close the windows while we were out. It made us feel like we were under surveillance. I also got way too many texts from this host. I couldn’t relax. The neighbors left a sticky note on our door asking to turn off the porch light. We ignored it because having the light on at night is for safety, and honestly not our problem that they were bothered by the properties porch light. Lastly, we had to take out all of the trash and put it into the bear box. If the host is so close, they should be able to take out the trash. Especially for the price. Overall, I wouldn’t stay here again.
airbnb
AudreyAugust 2026
Great location just minutes from all the restaurants, shops, and activities in Tahoe City. The house is charming, clean, and thoughtfully decorated. I do miss details like bathroom and area rugs that most rentals don't include anymore. The back deck appears to be a new addition, and new lounge furniture was delivered during our stay, making it an inviting spot to relax and enjoy the evenings. We visited during a stretch of 80+ degree weather, so the house was warm during the day without air conditioning. Fortunately, temperatures cooled off nicely at night, and with the fans provided, the home remained comfortable for sleeping.
airbnb
KateAugust 2026
The house is beautiful - and the setting was private and quiet. The deck in the morning and evening is lovely - a great place to gather. The house is good for a family of 4-5, but with beyond that or with grown kids it started to get a tight - the kid bedroom is small so not a lot of extra space to spread out. Not a show stopper because the house is great otherwise and the deck space makes up for it!
airbnb