Manager Review

Island Rentals, LLC reviews in Gulf Shores, Alabama

4.59

Island Rentals, LLC holds a 4.59 guest rating in Gulf Shores, Alabama, computed from 102 guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 45 of 53 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Gulf Shores, or homeowner reviews of Island Rentals, LLC on their profile.

Island Rentals, LLC's guest rating in Gulf Shores, Alabama of 4.59 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Gulf Shores.

Recent guest reviews in Gulf Shores

TaraSeptember 2026
“We enjoyed our week stay! Views are amazing, in both living room and from your master bed. Love the 2 options for pools, never seemed to be overly crowded at either. We'd definitely rent this unit again. Sunrise is gorgeous 😍”
airbnb
RynSeptember 2026
“The location is great. The beach in this area wasn't at all crowded. The condo was clean and the beds were comfortable, but the rest was disappointing. The patio door in the primary bedroom whistled in the wind and the other one was difficult to open and close. The weather stripping was falling off the front door and the keypad wouldn't lock about half way through our stay. The microwave above the stove wasn't working so there was a small one on the countertop. There was water damage/mold on the ceiling above the microwave and also in the primary bathroom. I was also disappointed that there was no beach supplies. I've never been to an Airbnb or VRBO at the beach that didn't at least have beach chairs. I asked for an early check-in by 2 hours. I figured that since I knew they weren't booked the day before our stay (they offered me a discount to come a day early) it wouldn't be a problem, but they charged me $35. It wasn't horrible, but not the best either. Overall, I did enjoy my stay.”
airbnb
TaylorSeptember 2026
“The chairs they have are completely not usable if you sit In them you’ll need a tetanus shot. The fridge went out and ruined $200 worth of groceries. We messaged they never came. Lucky for us my fiance was able to fix. It is small very small. The towels had make up all over them. They told us we couldn’t even be on property early which wasn’t so. You can the staff was happy to let you pay for your parking pass and come use the pool and beach. They offered zero help we had small kids and coming home 25 mins with tired kids with to no food and having to rush back to town and spend that money over was less than ideal. Will stay at kiva dunes again but not with this host.”
airbnb
BrandonAugust 2026
“Loved the place. The only complaint was having to pay for parking I thought it should be included in price”
airbnb
JacobAugust 2026
“Are hot water was turned off for some reason when we arrived. There was a lot of sand on the floor and under the couches. It was overall a pretty nice place and was a nice spot next to the beach. Did provide very many essentials and had to pay extra for parking.”
airbnb