Manager Review

Select Rentals in Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania

4.69

This is the local review page for Select Rentals in Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania. Amongst managers in Tobyhanna, Select Rentals currently ranks 3 of 5 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Tobyhanna, or see homeowner reviews of Select Rentals on their profile.

Select Rentals's guest rating in Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania of 4.69 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Tobyhanna.

Recent guest reviews

SophyaAugust 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Amazing Family Getaway! We had such an amazing stay in Tobyhanna, PA! The house was exactly as pictured—beautiful, clean, comfortable, and perfect for our family get-together. Our host was wonderful, very attentive, responsive, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout our stay. The country club amenities were a huge bonus! The pool was gorgeous and had such a fun atmosphere with music, great vibes, and a perfect vacation feel. The location was also super convenient, with supermarkets and Walmart just a short drive away. Camelback Waterpark is also nearby, which was perfect for some family fun! Having family come together from different states made this trip extra special, and this home was the perfect place for us to create some great memories. ❤️ We absolutely loved our stay and would definitely come back! Highly recommend this Airbnb for anyone looking for a relaxing, fun, and family-friendly Poconos getaway! 🏡✨
airbnb
SeemaAugust 2026
We had an absolutely amazing stay! The home was beautiful, immaculate, fresh, and incredibly clean. From the moment we arrived, we could tell how much care and attention goes into making the home welcoming and comfortable. The outdoor space and amenities were incredible and really made our trip special. We went kayaking, swimming, had a BBQ, and spent so much time just enjoying the property. We traveled with our five children, and there was truly something for everyone to enjoy. The kids had the best time, and so did we! The host was absolutely wonderful- so welcoming, accommodating, responsive, and thoughtful. Everything was so well taken care of, and the entire stay was seamless from beginning to end. It was the perfect place for our family to relax, have fun, and make great memories together. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and would absolutely love to come back. Highly recommend!
airbnb
MonikaJuly 2026
House is much smaller in real life than it appears in the pictures. Little messy kitchen drawers, messy deck. I give 4 stars because of CJ’s professional attitude and quick response to our messages. He provided us with missing kitchen items and send someone to clean the deck and repair the grill. Nice and easy check in and check out instructions. Very nice hot tub. We saw so many deer!! It was a highlight to those rainy days!!
airbnb
AniJuly 2026
We had an amazing stay at this lake house and would absolutely come back. The home was spotless, beautifully maintained, and had everything we needed for a relaxing getaway. The lake views were stunning, especially in the morning and at sunset, and the peaceful atmosphere made it easy to unwind. The host was friendly, responsive, and made check-in and check-out effortless. The house was well-stocked, comfortable, and thoughtfully designed, making it feel like a home away from home. We especially enjoyed spending time by the water and relaxing on the deck. If you’re looking for a clean, comfortable, and peaceful lakefront escape, this is the perfect place. We highly recommend it and can’t wait to return!
airbnb
JonJuly 2026
CJ was a great host. The team is very responsive for any needs. The house was as beautiful as the photos and we would love to stay here again! Thank you again for a relaxing weekend!
airbnb