Manager Review

Red Cottage in Windham, New York

4.96

This is the local review page for Red Cottage in Windham, New York. Amongst managers in Windham, Red Cottage currently ranks 2 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Windham, or see homeowner reviews of Red Cottage on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

SarahAugust 2026
Amazing stay, the perfect gateway. We will be back !
airbnb
HectorJuly 2026
Amazing, we loved your home!
airbnb
AidanJuly 2026
A beautiful home! I was able to propose with no issue! Am very grateful for the stay. Very beautiful home.
airbnb
SarahJuly 2026
We had a wonderful stay! The property is beautiful, peaceful, and very private—exactly what we were looking for. There were six of us, and there was more than enough space for everyone to spread out comfortably. The fire pit was a highlight of the trip, and the clear night skies made for incredible stargazing. We also loved the deck, which was the perfect place to BBQ and enjoy dinner together each evening. One thing to keep in mind, especially if you’re visiting in the summer: there is only one air conditioner in the main living area. The bedrooms have plug-in fans, which kept the rooms comfortable enough, but they didn’t get especially cool. We stayed in mid-July, so this is something future guests may want to consider. Overall, we had a great experience and would definitely recommend this property!
airbnb
RichJuly 2026
Our group had a lovely stay at the beautiful "disco house" over the 4th of July weekend. The setup was perfect, and all the amenities worked very well. There was an unfortunate power outage right at check-in, and given the weak cell signals up on the hill, a member of our party did have to drive back to the highway to communicate with the hosts, but they were very responsive and helpful in resolving it quickly. Be mindful that there is only A/C unit in the main room, but the bedrooms all have very good fans. We were fortunate that the temperatures fell at the end of the big heat wave, and were comfortable. Loved hanging outside under the overhang during some cool rainstorms!
airbnb