Manager Review

Red Cottage in New York

Red Cottage's guest reviews across New York. See homeowner reviews of Red Cottage on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

Amber NJune 2026Town Of Cochecton
Overall we were happy with our stay. It was nice to find a spot that was pretty secluded but comfortable enough for everyone to relax with the amenities of being in a home. The space is beautifully decorated, towels are extra plush, beds were stiff but not overly so and after you settle in they were quite comfortable, kitchen was decently stocked (as of our trip it could have used a coffee grinder, cheese grater and 9x13 baking dish but we shared this with the team so perhaps the next guests will have them), love the shampoo/conditioner/bodywash brand - clean ingredients and smell great! We had some issues during our stay and response time was decent considering it was the middle of the night. Note - future guests may need to request for the flood lights to be turned off, they kind of defeat the purpose of being in the dark, seeing stars, and getting a decent night sleep. The basement also had some cleaning issues that sound like they will be resolved soon. Overall recommended!
airbnb
JustinJune 2026Leeds
Hands down one of the best properties I have stayed at thus far. Every detail in the house was meticulously & intentionally thought out to ensure max comfort & convenience (from pool towels , blanket placement , to well labeled kitchen items & so much more). The host was exceptionally responsive & even sent us a new pool skimmer in a matter of hours when we couldn’t find one around the house ! The pool was well heated & the views were breath taking. Will definitely be coming back again!
airbnb
HollyJune 2026Livingston Manor
We loved everything about our stay. It had everything we needed including a great hot tub! Location is great. We hope we can stay again. Highly recommend for families.
airbnb
SamJune 2026Athens
Super nice house. Great property. Close to Hudson. Easy to communicate with the owners. Had to pay to check in a couple hours early, but overall I’d recommend!
airbnb
MitchellJune 2026Saugerties
Red Cottage was a beautiful home and had everything the family needed for our stay. They were responsive to any questions we had during our stay. The pictures don't do justice to how beautiful and special this home is. The kitchen was fully stocked with all of the basics you need to cook. They even had dishes for inside the home or if you wanted to eat out on the beautiful deck Each of the bedrooms were very comfortable. There were plenty of games and toys for all ages! It was a wonderful home!! We highly recommend this home for your family.
airbnb

Amongst managers in New York, Red Cottage currently ranks 3/18 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in New York.