Manager Review

Red Cottage in Prattsville, New York

4.59

This is the local review page for Red Cottage in Prattsville, New York. Amongst managers in Prattsville, Red Cottage currently ranks 2 of 2 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Prattsville, or see homeowner reviews of Red Cottage on their profile.

Red Cottage's guest rating in Prattsville, New York of 4.59 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Prattsville.

Recent guest reviews

LenaAugust 2026
“Such a lovely and cozy cottage, spacious, clean, stocked ! Beautiful, peaceful surroundings and everything we needed for a relaxing stay. We really enjoyed our time here and would happily come back!”
airbnb
SonnyJuly 2026
“This was place was beautiful! We all had such a great time in nature, our host recommended some hiking spots, which was so helpful! I definitely recommend this place! They were easy to communicate with and replied fast if we had any questions!”
airbnb
IsabellaJune 2026
“The house was very nice and as pictured however, the sheets in the bed downstairs were not clean and beds were quite uncomfortable. Upon arrival, the hot tub ph and chlorine was off so we couldn’t even use it after reaching out. The grill was also not able to be used because it was dirty and there was no scraper to clean it off. We were excited to use both amenities and were really disappointed that we were unable to utilize them. There was plenty of seating and space for 8 of us to enjoy. Many games, tv streaming, and spacious and well stocked kitchen. The espresso machine was a great addition as well as firewood available for the pit outside! A few more chairs for the fire pit would have been nice. The host was very communicative and kind from beginning to end but unfortunately wasn’t able to fix most issues we had during our stay such as cleanliness and hot tub issues. A beautiful home with beautiful scenery, but there were a few notable inconveniences.”
airbnb
ClaireMay 2026
“Great spot to stay with a good group! Whether it’s cold and rainy or warm and sunny. Took a second to get used to the sulfurous smell in the bathroom but plenty of candles are provided! Really loved our time in this sweet home.”
airbnb
Mary KatherineMarch 2026
“We enjoyed the peace and tranquility of the location, the beautiful views from the deck and lounging in the various common spaces. Everything was clean and well maintained for our stay. We wished they had some lights on the hot tub side of the deck, and a few more towels, but those are minor details from an otherwise lovely trip. We would definitely come back and stay again.”
airbnb