Manager Review

Fairly reviews in Penn Yan, New York

Fairly holds a 5.00 guest rating in Penn Yan, New York, computed from 10 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 1 of 6 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Penn Yan, or homeowner reviews of Fairly on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Penn Yan

GuruOctober 2026
“Excellent place to stay at this price point in the Finger Lakes. Great location in Penn Yan, 5ish minute walk to Main Street. Got a lovely coffee shop and farm style grocery store around the block. Short drive to a bunch of very good wineries. If you don’t want to stay 20-30 outside of one the main towns, this is a very good option. Very responsive host and easy check in/check out procedures. I wouldn’t hesitate to book this Airbnb again.”
airbnb
ChelseaSeptember 2026
“This Victorian home was a perfect spot for our Keuka Lake adventures. We really enjoyed the town and being able to walk to restaurants after a day in wine country. The game room was a fun addition, it had been years since we played MsPacMan!! We found everything we needed in the house and greatly appreciate the owners opening up their home.”
airbnb
AmitSeptember 2026
“Old Victorian home with antique furniture”
airbnb
HaroldAugust 2026
“Gerat place. We look forward to returning.”
airbnb
DianeAugust 2026
“House was in a perfect location to take advantage of Keuka Lake and all of the local wineries, breweries etc. We found a fantastic 9 hole golf course with a great bar and restaurant(open all year) - “Arrowhead Creek” to offer even more options. The home was a terrific space and the bedrooms - all had queen size beds and large spacious rooms. Plenty of room to spread out and relax. We’ll be back!”
airbnb