Manager Review

Red Cottage reviews in Narrowsburg, New York

Red Cottage holds a 4.89 guest rating in Narrowsburg, New York, computed from 151 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 2 of 2 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Narrowsburg, or homeowner reviews of Red Cottage on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Narrowsburg

JamesOctober 2026
“Absolutely beautiful home with breathtaking views! The house was spotless, beautifully maintained, and had everything we needed for a perfect stay. We especially loved the kitchen, which was great for cooking, as well as the nearby hiking trails and incredible eagle watching. Everything made for such a relaxing and memorable getaway. We highly recommend this stay and would absolutely love to come back!”
airbnb
SymphaniOctober 2026
“It’s a lively home and prefect location. 8 mins away from the town. The outdoor space was nice and spacious. Master bedroom bed extremely comfortable and living room couch was comfortable. It was hard finding the right light switches. The cookware pots and pans. Need a little upgrade that was a disappointment. The grill outside needs some TLC big time.”
airbnb
DavidOctober 2026
“This place is even better than described. Forget how great the central Narrowsburg location is along with all the surrounding area has to offer. This house is incredible, giving you the best of a Rivertown Main Street vibe with the perfect backyard hang and serene water front to boot. We can’t wait to come back to this house.”
airbnb
SanOctober 2026
“The Narrowsburg property was perfect for our family stay. It has great and easy lake access. The home is remote and private. Short drive to small neighboring towns north and south of the property. The overall home and appliances and amenities were all modern and well constructed. The master bedroom provides a spectacular view. It does get pretty sunny inside in the afternoon.”
airbnb
KelvinOctober 2026
“We had an amazing stay at this house. It's very well equipped, has great amenities and a stunning view!”
airbnb