Manager Review

Fairly reviews in Melville, New York

Fairly holds a 4.96 guest rating in Melville, New York, computed from 28 Airbnb guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Melville, or homeowner reviews of Fairly on their profile.

Recent guest reviews in Melville

AndreaOctober 2026
“We felt right at home from the minute we opened the door. The house had so many different spaces to relax and the backyard is beautiful. A really well kept safe neighborhood with very friendly neighbors. The host is friendly and responsive. There was even a gift basket with treats to welcome us. This host thought of everything! Book this one. You will not be disappointed. We will be back!”
airbnb
HarryOctober 2026
“Best place no disappoints.”
airbnb
RobertOctober 2026
“This was such a wonderful place to stay. The hosts have a lovely home; it was extremely clean, organized, and offered amenities such as washer and dryer, dishwasher, etc. Hosts were also easy to reach, communicative, and respectful. This was an amazing place to stay for my family and I for the weekend!”
airbnb
AmandaOctober 2026
“Great stay. Host was amazing and even helped us get a new coffee machine when it didn’t work and got us a baby bathtub as well”
airbnb
GardySeptember 2026
“Outstanding Stay – Exceptionally Clean, Neat, and Comfortable!** > We had a wonderful stay at Fairly’s place in Melville! From the moment we walked in, it was clear how much care and attention goes into maintaining the property. The house was spotlessly clean, incredibly neat, and perfectly organized in every room. > The setup was ideal for our group—vibrant, spacious, and very comfortable. Communication with Fairly was smooth and accommodating throughout our stay. If you’re looking for a squeaky-clean, relaxing, and hassle-free place to stay in Long Island, I highly recommend booking here. We’d love to stay again!”
airbnb