Manager Review

Red Cottage in Jeffersonville, New York

4.81

This is the local review page for Red Cottage in Jeffersonville, New York. Amongst managers in Jeffersonville, Red Cottage currently ranks 2 of 2 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Jeffersonville, or see homeowner reviews of Red Cottage on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

GregoryAugust 2026
This is a beautiful property. It really feels like a home away from home with lots of interesting books and furnishings. Would happily stay again.
airbnb
JenniferJuly 2026
The house is beautiful, old and modern all at once! Great for back porch woodsy views and relaxation. We stayed for concerts at Bethel Woods; absolutely ideal for this location.
airbnb
PauloFebruary 2026
The house was exactly as described in the listing and photos. We had an amazing weekend. Everything was incredible. We would definitely come back.
airbnb
JordanJanuary 2026
Better than the pictures! Beautiful home and surrounding area. Came during December/January and would definitely come back in the fall for the foliage change. Bedrooms were roomy and bed was comfy. Kitchen was a great size to cook in. Hosts were very responsive.
airbnb
December 2025
This was one of my favorite Airbnbs we have ever stayed at! So clean and cozy with historic charm. We visited during the holidays, and it looked like a home from a Hallmark movie! The hosts had it decorated for Christmas, and we were so happy there. The beds were comfortable, and everything was thoughtfully decorated and so charming. Our two toddlers were very comfortable there as well. The finished basement with a TV was a nice touch. Thank you for a wonderful stay! My only tip for future guests is to bring what you need - deliveries to this location are a bit difficult for us. The good news is that there is a town close by where you can drive to get what you need before or after arrival. Overall, fantastic Airbnb!
airbnb