Manager Review

Red Cottage in Hampton Bays, New York

4.62

This is the local review page for Red Cottage in Hampton Bays, New York. Amongst managers in Hampton Bays, Red Cottage currently ranks 4 of 4 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Hampton Bays, or see homeowner reviews of Red Cottage on their profile.

Red Cottage's guest rating in Hampton Bays, New York of 4.62 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Hampton Bays.

Recent guest reviews

JessicaAugust 2026
I HIGHLY recommend Red Cottage as a rental agency, but not this particular house. HOUSE: modern, cute minimalist vibe. BUT there were significant issues: ant infestation in the bathroom; rugs dirty with food gunk adhered to them; closets packed with the owners' stuff, even muddy boots; filthy kitchen supplies...grease-covered pots/pans, flakes of teflon coming off; tick-infested cushions on the patio furniture. There were also major structural problems: the septic tank backed up and clogged the showers and toilets. The entire ceiling in the second bathroom leaked...water dripping down. RED COTTAGE: The agency was TERRIFIC. They responded quickly to all of the problems with the house and worked with us to arrive at a fair resolution when we checked out early because of the ceiling leak. They checked in regularly to see how things were going and to find solutions when problems arose. The sent repair people in a timely fashion. I would DEFINITELY rent a different house from them again.
airbnb
JeffreyJune 2026
Amazing location and amenities. Perfect weekend getaway location. Patio/pool area were great.
airbnb
September 2025
The stay was great
airbnb
September 2025
We stayed here for our wedding weekend and we never wanted to leave! The home and property are absolutely beautiful, exactly as pictured. We will definitely be back! This home will always hold a special place in our heart.
airbnb
September 2025
My family had a great 10 day stay! Felt right at home and really got to relax and enjoy the peaceful pool/hot tub! Highly recommended!
airbnb