Manager Review

Red Cottage in Fleischmanns, New York

4.74

This is the local review page for Red Cottage in Fleischmanns, New York. Amongst managers in Fleischmanns, Red Cottage currently ranks 3 of 3 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Fleischmanns, or see homeowner reviews of Red Cottage on their profile.

Red Cottage's guest rating in Fleischmanns, New York of 4.74 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Fleischmanns.

Recent guest reviews

KateAugust 2026
We had a fabulous family vacation in this unique space with its giant ceiling and massive beams. Belleayre Barn is beautifully designed with spaces on different levels for hanging out. We appreciated the antique furnishings and decor throughout. Pool table, chess, board games, a big comfy sectional for watching movies...it's impossible to get bored here. The weather was great during our stay, so we were mostly outdoors. We loved the deck and fire pit. Unfortunately the hot tub had a malfunction while we were there, but Red Cottage promptly offered to adjust our payment accordingly to reflect this. Also, our stay was in August, and the lack of AC was not a problem in the least - the weather was cool and we even ended up shutting the windows and screen doors sometimes. There are fans available if needed. The bedrooms are private and comfortable (though noise does carry a bit from room to room because of the barn structure). Can't wait to go back!
airbnb
RosemaryAugust 2026
The hosts were responsive and helpful. The home is beautiful creating a peaceful environment with the surroundings greenery and great location for a large group of friends. Would recommend!
airbnb
MotyAugust 2026
We had a grand time. The views outside are amazing.
airbnb
SolAugust 2026
If you’re looking for a peaceful, unique experience then this is the place for you and your loved ones. Being an actual barn converted into an airbnb, it looks like no other rental on this app. Exposed interior beams, the smell of wood throughout the home, and a quiet and pleasant view to enjoy your morning coffee leaves you in such a cozy state that you’ll ask yourself why didn’t I book another day or two. The host was very attentive, instructions were clear and concise, and they allow your furry friends to spend the time with you. We can’t wait to come back!
airbnb
AmirJuly 2026
Lovely, peaceful stay with helpful, responsive hosts. Looking forward to staying here again with a larger group!
airbnb