Manager Review

Red Cottage in East Chatham, New York

4.94

This is the local review page for Red Cottage in East Chatham, New York. Amongst managers in East Chatham, Red Cottage currently ranks 1 of 2 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in East Chatham, or see homeowner reviews of Red Cottage on their profile.

Recent guest reviews

GeorgiaMay 2026
Wonderful stay with a stunning view and open layout, perfect for a weekend away with friends/family.
airbnb
MariaFebruary 2026
We had a wonderful long weekend here. The house is beautiful. It had everything we needed and communication with the host was great. We would love to go back.
airbnb
RachelJanuary 2026
Amazing stay! You will need 4 wheel drive in winter:
airbnb
November 2025
This house was really nice for a relaxing week away from home. The kitchen is well stocked with pots, pans, etc. so we could cook anything we wanted. We loved the steam shower and heated floors in the primary bath too. The area has some cute farm stores and co-ops that were fun to explore.
airbnb
October 2025
The view is truly spectacular, and the large sliding doors and fireplace made the space feel cozy. The house was also well stocked, which we appreciated. The management company was also extremely responsive. However, the home felt in need of a deeper clean. An upstairs door didn’t fully close, so there were bugs inside when we arrived. The upstairs balcony wasn’t available for use and we also had a few maintenance issues: the fire alarm went off without reason one day, and the central heating was stuck on one temperature throughout our stay.
airbnb