Manager Review

Stay Heirloom in Nantucket, Massachusetts

4.79

This is the local review page for Stay Heirloom in Nantucket, Massachusetts. Amongst managers in Nantucket, Stay Heirloom currently ranks 4 of 4 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Nantucket, or see homeowner reviews of Stay Heirloom on their profile.

Stay Heirloom's guest rating in Nantucket, Massachusetts of 4.79 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Nantucket.

Recent guest reviews

LisaAugust 2026
“This property is lovely, we booked the cottage and the carriage house for our group of 10 and the central outdoor gathering space was awesome. We took full advantage of the firepit, hot tub, and pool... and the landscaping is lush and green with white roses surrounding the property.”
airbnb
JuliaAugust 2026
“This place was great for my friends and I! The location was perfect, a 10 minute walk to town. The yard and outdoor shower were great, and the living room was very cozy for hanging out and playing games. The beds were very comfortable and lots of extra towels and linens. Heirloom was very quick to respond if we had any questions or needed something. Would definitely come back!”
airbnb
CharlieAugust 2026
“great”
airbnb
Kathleen MAugust 2026
“Wonderful family vacation!!! Beautiful home.”
airbnb
JulianaAugust 2026
“We had a wonderful stay here! The location was great. It was in a quiet area and only about a 17-minute walk into town. The space was clean, comfortable, and exactly what we needed for our stay. The hosts were incredibly helpful and responsive, always quick to answer any questions. We also really appreciated how flexible and accommodating the hosts were with letting us leave our bags and working with us on a later check-out when possible. They truly went above and beyond to make our stay easy and enjoyable. We would absolutely stay here again and would highly recommend it to family and friends visiting Nantucket!”
airbnb