Manager Review

Fairly in Mccall, Idaho

4.71

This is the local review page for Fairly in Mccall, Idaho. Amongst managers in Mccall, Fairly currently ranks 4 of 5 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Mccall, or see homeowner reviews of Fairly on their profile.

Fairly's guest rating in Mccall, Idaho of 4.71 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Mccall.

Recent guest reviews

MichelleAugust 2026
The home is beautiful, in a beautiful location and not too far from the lake. We enjoyed our stay very much and it would have been perfect if not for the construction occurring on the house in the back and the need for a good deep cleaning. It was a bit too dusty, and trash was left behind, but I am picky I suppose. Our check in was delayed but our host made it up with a gift card for a local restaurant. Overall a very enjoyable experience.
airbnb
SteveAugust 2026
Wonderful!! Thank you so much!!
airbnb
ShawnAugust 2026
Nice home, quiet and close to grocery and town. Access to HOA pool and courts was great. Hot tub outside master bedroom was a nice touch. Could use a few more things like more utensils and lighters, an ax for chopping wood smaller for fire pit. Maybe even a hose for access to water in case fire pit gets out of control. Pictures of the place are done in a way that makes it appear larger than it is. Like the bedrooms look quite a bit bigger but are kind of cramped. Bikes in garage we don't have access to, but not sure they were mentioned in the listing so no worries. Overall a decent place and experience. The property mgmt company is pretty responsive and helpful. That makes a difference.
airbnb
CortniAugust 2026
I highly recommend this home. We have been visiting McCall every summer for the past 15 years & this has been our favorite stay so far. The location was perfect for us - so easy to bike into town & to Ponderosa State Park. There was ample parking & boat parking was great. The large garage was perfect for storing our outdoor gear. The outdoor screened in area is amazing. And the fenced yard is large and beautiful. The inside was clean & comfortable. The master bed/bath is especially nice. We visited during a hotter-than-usual time & the window fans for nighttime air were very appreciated. The linens were all very comfortable. And, the shampoo, conditioner, body wash was very nice & appreciated. The laundry facilities were great & lots of hangers and closet space. We also appreciated little additions like freezer packs, fun board games, plenty of hooks in bathrooms for multiple towels. The hosts were extremely friendly & responsive as well. Fantastic stay!
airbnb
LauraJuly 2026
The property manager was very responsive and very nice. And there wasn’t a super long list of chores to do before checkout. I really appreciated those things. However, it was frustrating having to wait until 4:00 to check in, and when I tried to, the code for the door didn’t work. Once we got inside, the house was very cute and looked like it’s pictures, but on further inspection the floors were grimy and the beds looked as though they had not been cleaned after the last guest. There were a spare set of clean sheets available that were ended up using, but the need to switch them was rather frustrating.
airbnb