Manager Review

Christian Taylor Vacations in Island Park, Idaho

4.50

This is the local review page for Christian Taylor Vacations in Island Park, Idaho. Amongst managers in Island Park, Christian Taylor Vacations currently ranks 15 of 16 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Island Park, or see homeowner reviews of Christian Taylor Vacations on their profile.

Christian Taylor Vacations's guest rating in Island Park, Idaho of 4.50 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Island Park.

Recent guest reviews

AkramAugust 2026
We stayed at Debra Ann's condo at Timbers for two nights during a Yellowstone trip, and it provided a peaceful, comfortable base after long days in the park. The unit is exactly as pictured in the listing. Debra Ann was a genuine highlight — warm, responsive, and thoughtful, with detailed local recommendations. A few things to note, mostly involving the on-site front desk rather than Debra Ann herself: we were told someone would be available for our after-9 PM arrival, but no one was there, so we sorted out the lockbox code by phone. At the desk, we were also asked to sign for a resort fee and a higher card hold than the check-in message indicated — Debra Ann addressed both right away and confirmed we shouldn't be charged. One thing worth noting: the listing shows a 9 PM checkout, but the front desk (the property association) told us checkout is actually 10 AM, so plan for 10 AM to be safe. Note that the unit has no A/C (a box fan and ceiling fan are provided).
airbnb
ZoeJuly 2026
We had a great stay overall, there is a grocery store nearby which makes it very convenient. However, the rooms don’t really have good ventilation, can be a little hot during the summer.
airbnb
丹阳June 2026
great position and nice host
airbnb
September 2024
Neat, clean, roomy and in a great location for visiting local national parks. The clubhouse and pool were a nice bonus.
airbnb
September 2024
Nice community and we enjoyed the pool and hot tub. Connie’s is a nice place for dinner but get there by 6:00 before the rush. Debbie was easy to communicate with. We had some issues with the condo association that were not Debbie’s fault which were easily dealt with.
airbnb