Manager Review

Wander in Marathon, Florida

4.44

This is the local review page for Wander in Marathon, Florida. Amongst managers in Marathon, Wander currently ranks 15 of 16 on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Marathon, or see homeowner reviews of Wander on their profile.

Wander's guest rating in Marathon, Florida of 4.44 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Marathon.

Recent guest reviews

StacyApril 2026
This property was amazing. The view was incredible, the home was gorgeous, and the pool and hot tub were perfect
airbnb
BrandyFebruary 2026
Location was great and so was the home. Lovely. However, the hot tub doesn’t heat well or fast and is left cold, so if you want to use it, good luck. The patio in the bottom can’t be left open as some blaring alarm goes off when the doors are left open, which is bad as that’s the location you want to eat and enjoy with the doors open. We asked about it and we’re told it is the way it is with the pool. Maybe; but either way you won’t be able to enjoy the lower space with the doors open.
airbnb
DavidJanuary 2026
They had no extra paper towels or toilet paper. They did have it delivered a few hours later. Pool heater was a nightmare as once it got cold they could not get it back up to temperature. The dishwasher was not attached to the cabinet so it kept tilting when being loaded or slid out. Had 3 washers and 3 dryers so that was excellent. How was very nice otherwise.
airbnb
December 2025
We have rented in Marathon for less than what we paid and house was nicer and got great response from host. The jacuzzi never worked and they didn’t address it. The pool doesn’t get sun at any time so we couldn’t use it. The garage codes never worked to open. We had to open from the inside. I wouldn’t go there again.
airbnb
September 2025
The house is a dream! Great amenities, has everything you could need! First level not only has a large table, commercial size fridge, ice maker, just perfect for entertaining/ and celebrating our bachelorette weekend. And of course , Great location to just enjoy the Florida Keys and relax ! The dock is under construction, but only affected us part of the day! John was always very responsive, and check-in was very easy. Absolutely recommend, and would definitely stay here again.
airbnb