Manager Review

Fairly reviews in Mendocino County, California

4.78

Fairly holds a 4.78 guest rating in Mendocino County, California, computed from 50 guest reviews across the vacation rentals they manage there. That ranks them 2 of 5 managers in the market on guest satisfaction. See the top ranked vacation rental managers in Mendocino County, or homeowner reviews of Fairly on their profile.

Fairly's guest rating in Mendocino County, California of 4.78 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract. You can see higher-rated managers in Mendocino County.

Recent guest reviews in Mendocino County

Catriona RoseSeptember 2026
“Beautiful location, spacious beautiful home. We hope to come back!”
airbnb
JimSeptember 2026
“Charming, well-appointed, peaceful and comfortable. We really enjoyed our stay.”
airbnb
RandallAugust 2026
“The home has a gorgeous view. It sits on top of the bluff in Gualala. The home was very comfortable and well laid out”
airbnb
MarinaAugust 2026
“This was our second visit to MoonStar Cottage. We stayed here 10yrs ago and love the location. You seriously cannot beat the view. It’s GORGEOUS! With that said, hopefully if we come back, it will have a few upgrades for the increased prices that were added because literally nothing had changed. Same furniture and decor. We did have a little hiccup with the dated oven BUT the host arrived within minutes! The host Jennifer and Jason were fabulous! I would recommend it!”
airbnb
KimAugust 2026
“Responsive and kind host! Incredible ocean view, which you can see from large windows in the living room and main bedroom-both also have sliders to gigantic two level back deck w/seating. Very peaceful. Bed was big and very comfortable with great linens. Lots of soft towels. Layout would easily allow 6 guests comfortably. We were notified upon arrival that the dishwasher had broken and was getting replaced after our stay. Host allowed us the check in a few hours early, and that felt like a nice offset for the inconvenience. House overall was very clean-w/the exception there was some dog hair on the rug and living room couch when we arrived. I was glad to be able to bring our own dog and understand this can be part of a dog-friendly residence. Was not a big deal. House well cared for. Nice appliances and kitchenware. It sits on HWY1, but street noise felt minimal. Large property and is only a few miles to restaurants, beaches, shops, etc. We would definitely stay here again <3”
airbnb