Manager Review

Prime Vacations

Prime Vacations' homes average 4.72 stars across more than 6,000 Airbnb guest reviews on Anna Maria Island, Siesta Key and the Bradenton–Sarasota coast, close to the local average overall. In Anna Maria, its largest market, it scores 4.69 against a local average of 4.78.

What guests say: Guests praise the island locations, pools and short walks to the beach. In the lower-rated reviews, the complaints are homes that felt like you get what you pay for, with worn furnishings and maintenance misses compared with pricier rentals nearby.

How it works: Prime Vacations was founded in 2017 on Anna Maria Island and operates under a family of local brands across Anna Maria, Bradenton, Siesta Key, Lido Key and the St. Pete–Clearwater area, managing more than 1,000 homes. In 2024 StayTerra, backed by the private investment firm Garnett Station Partners, took a majority stake in the business. StayTerra and Prime have since sued members of Prime's founding family, alleging breaches of management and non-compete agreements; the case is ongoing.

What it costs: Prime doesn't publish its commission or contract terms. Get the rate, fees and termination terms in writing, and ask which company and team will actually manage your home.

Watch-outs: It does well in Siesta Key (4.78, ahead of most local competitors) and Bradenton Beach (4.76). It trails in Holmes Beach (4.72 vs. 4.83) and Bradenton (4.65 vs. 4.83).

Best fit: Owners on Siesta Key and Bradenton Beach, where Prime's record is strongest, who are comfortable with its recent change in ownership.

Prime Vacations's guest rating of 4.72 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review Prime Vacations.

Recent guest reviews

KarissaNovember 2026Anna Maria, Florida
“I would not stay again. You get what you pay for, this place is considerably more affordable than others in the area and it shows. While the location is great because it is walkable to the beach the walkable area from the home is really not great for families with small children. It was overgrown and muddy. The backyard porch area had garbage , glass, bottle caps & cigarette butts. I did not feel comfortable letting my child play in the sand. Secondly the layout is just not conducive for families. There are many steps without a gate or barrier. This would be fine for a group with adults or teens. The place you want to be is upstairs because of the view ( although there is porter pottie with construction there right outside the window now). Unfortunately the kitchen is down stairs and the big living room couch and tv is upstairs. The layout just doesn’t work well. Beach chairs and a wagon was provided but also left out in the elements so they were not in great condition.”
airbnb
FlaviaNovember 2026Anna Maria, Florida
“Quaint Little House in a Great Location! This quaint little house is in a fantastic location, right by the beach, with beautiful views! We really enjoyed our stay and had a wonderful time. The only downside for me was having just one bathroom, especially since we were traveling with another couple. It didn’t ruin our stay, but it was a bit inconvenient. The bathroom could also use some updating. The showerhead and fixtures need some attention, and the water pressure in the bathroom sink is quite low. The deck is lovely and a great place to relax, although some additional lighting would make it even better, especially in the evenings. Overall, we had a great experience and would definitely consider staying here again! However, next time I would book it just for our family of four, as I think the space is better suited for one family rather than two couples.”
airbnb
DianelysNovember 2026North Redington Beach, Florida
“Our stay was perfect i love the location and the view from the apartment was exceptional,the only thing you have to be sure of bring everything you need for you stay like paper towel,detergent,shampoo,conditioner,body wash,and some essentials for the days ,but i recomended 100% to others people .”
airbnb
CindyOctober 2026North Redington Beach, Florida
“Our stay was beautiful!! The view was spectacular. The condo was immaculate. Plenty of towels and a full kitchen Was like being at home. So spacious”
airbnb
JenniferOctober 2026North Redington Beach, Florida
“We loved this place! Gorgeous view, clean, safe. Make sure you bring your own coffee, paper towels, salt and pepper etc because there aren’t starters there. You will have TP and little soap bars and 2 dishwasher pods.”
airbnb
NancyOctober 2026Bradenton, Florida
“Wonderful ! Wonderful! Wonderful! Loved every moment we were there!”
airbnb
Rae AnneOctober 2026Anna Maria, Florida
“Beautiful place however the listing was inaccurate. It lists a 4th bedroom with a bathroom in a building right next to house and also listed outside shower and other things that we did not have access to. One of the reasons we booked this place was because of the additional bed & bath. We were disappointed to find out we did not have access to it considering it was listed in the posting.”
airbnb
RebeccaAugust 2026Siesta Key, Florida
“Good condo! Great kitchen amenities!”
airbnb
YudelsyAugust 2026Sarasota, Florida
“Very nice! And pleasant stay! Near to the Beach. ❤️”
airbnb
OliviaApril 2026Siesta Key, Florida
“Had a wonderful week with the family. Perfect location, 2 minute walk to the beach and 15 minute walk to the village.”
airbnb

Local Rankings