Prime Vacations
Prime Vacations' homes average 4.72 stars across more than 6,000 Airbnb guest reviews on Anna Maria Island, Siesta Key and the Bradenton–Sarasota coast, close to the local average overall. In Anna Maria, its largest market, it scores 4.69 against a local average of 4.78.
What guests say: Guests praise the island locations, pools and short walks to the beach. In the lower-rated reviews, the complaints are homes that felt like you get what you pay for, with worn furnishings and maintenance misses compared with pricier rentals nearby.
How it works: Prime Vacations was founded in 2017 on Anna Maria Island and operates under a family of local brands across Anna Maria, Bradenton, Siesta Key, Lido Key and the St. Pete–Clearwater area, managing more than 1,000 homes. In 2024 StayTerra, backed by the private investment firm Garnett Station Partners, took a majority stake in the business. StayTerra and Prime have since sued members of Prime's founding family, alleging breaches of management and non-compete agreements; the case is ongoing.
What it costs: Prime doesn't publish its commission or contract terms. Get the rate, fees and termination terms in writing, and ask which company and team will actually manage your home.
Watch-outs: It does well in Siesta Key (4.78, ahead of most local competitors) and Bradenton Beach (4.76). It trails in Holmes Beach (4.72 vs. 4.83) and Bradenton (4.65 vs. 4.83).
Best fit: Owners on Siesta Key and Bradenton Beach, where Prime's record is strongest, who are comfortable with its recent change in ownership.
Verified Homeowner Reviews
Write a reviewNo homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review Prime Vacations.
Recent guest reviews
Local Rankings
- Reviews of Prime Vacations in Siesta Key, Florida
- Reviews of Prime Vacations in Sarasota, Florida
- Reviews of Prime Vacations in Holmes Beach, Florida
- Reviews of Prime Vacations in Anna Maria, Florida
- Reviews of Prime Vacations in Bradenton Beach, Florida
- Reviews of Prime Vacations in Indian Shores, Florida
- Reviews of Prime Vacations in Bradenton, Florida
- Reviews of Prime Vacations in North Redington Beach, Florida
- Reviews of Prime Vacations in Cortez, Florida