Manager Review

Ocean Colony Beach

Ocean Colony Beach's guest rating of 4.71 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review Ocean Colony Beach.

Recent guest reviews

KarlOctober 2026Amagansett, New York
“Amazing weekend stay! We had the ocean view right from our living room and spoted Humpback Whales one morning! Simply beautiful.”
airbnb
LauraSeptember 2026Amagansett, New York
“Really lovely location, beautifully updated place. Made for a great stay!”
airbnb
BrittanySeptember 2026Amagansett, New York
“Great place to stay! Very conveniently located between east Hampton and montauk. Great food options right next door. Listing very accurate for what you got!”
airbnb
MeghanSeptember 2026Amagansett, New York
“My only complaint is there was not a full-length mirror. Everything else was amazing!”
airbnb
JulieSeptember 2026Amagansett, New York
“Great stay but the place smells.”
airbnb
NmpSeptember 2026Amagansett, New York
“Unfortunately, our stay was disappointing. We arrived at almost 5:00 PM, and the apartment was still not ready or cleaned. We had to wait until around 5:45 PM before we could get in. The person at the front desk was not rude, but the instructions on how to find the apartment were very vague. The location of the apartment is a little tricky and confusing, so clearer directions would have been very helpful. The Wi-Fi was not working, which also meant we could not connect to or use the TVs. We were traveling with a child, so this was especially inconvenient. If it had just been adults, the TV would not have been such a big issue for me. The apartment also needs much better lighting. The kitchen only has one light, and the bedrooms only have lamps. All of the lamps were unplugged when we arrived, so at first we thought they did not work. In addition, the curtain in the bedroom was broken and could not be closed properly, so a lot of light came into the room. Overall, I think the apart”
airbnb
BayneSeptember 2026Amagansett, New York
“Our stay was great! The location and amenities are awesome and it’s so close to everything we were looking to do while staying. Highly recommend.”
airbnb
SierraSeptember 2026Amagansett, New York
“Loved our stay, the beach access was wonderful!!”
airbnb
GJuly 2026Amagansett, New York
“Great space, well-maintained, clean, easy walk to beach, beach attendants were great, office mostly responsive except for check in/out times differing by an hour versus the listing. (Check in 1 h later/ckout 1 hr earlier than stated in listing.) When I messaged about it, response was “sorry for the discrepancy, we’ll message you as soon as the unit is ready”. No follow up was sent. I think if we’d tried to check in at the listed time it may have been fine, but it was an unnecessary annoyance in an otherwise lovely stay.”
airbnb
Roxanna GraceJuly 2026Amagansett, New York
“We came for 4th of July weekend and had a great time. The place was extremely well located and the beach access that came with it was superb. Giving 4 stars because given how expensive the home was, we expected better condition. We had to get a few things repaired during our stay. We also originally only had 4 shower towels despite booking for 6 guests.”
airbnb

Local Rankings