Manager Review

Mill Pond Realty

Mill Pond Realty's guest rating of 4.75 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review Mill Pond Realty.

Recent guest reviews

AmySeptember 2026Saugatuck, Michigan
“Went for a girls weekend and this was the perfect spot. Clean, comfortable bedrooms, furniture, plenty of space. Loved it!”
airbnb
ShivaniSeptember 2026Saugatuck, Michigan
“Great location and home for a weekend getaway with room to spread out, backyard space is great with fire pit and everything you need in the kitchen for easy meal prep!”
airbnb
KatieSeptember 2026Saugatuck, Michigan
“Loved how close everything was!”
airbnb
SarahSeptember 2026Saugatuck, Michigan
“Location is incredible, and while the space is small, it was just what we needed as a family of three for a long weekend trip.”
airbnb
ReganMaryAugust 2026Fennville, Michigan
“The description was as listed. Going to a secondary location for check in was inconvenient. The home was not as clean as I would’ve preferred but overall it was a nice home.”
airbnb
MeganJuly 2026Fennville, Michigan
“Great place if you want to be close to town and walking distance to the water! We enjoyed our stay, but beware of the WiFi/service available. All 7 of us had issues getting kicked off the WiFi several times a day, failed calls, etc. Not just in the house, but the area as well. One of our friends went out to get food and couldn’t access maps or call us for help.”
airbnb
WilJuly 2026Douglas, Michigan
“Loved the home. Only problem was the HVAC. Home never cooled below 75. Brought it up to rental company immediately but never could get anyone out to look at it.”
airbnb
JacquelynJune 2026Fennville, Michigan
“Beautiful home and property (Logom) on one of the best streets in the area. We love the Glenn store and everything the area has to offer. The check in and check out processes diverge from normal AirBNB expectations. The beach is dangerous due to old metal debris. In order to get to a safe swimming spot, we had to walk quite a ways north, which was probably private property. Another, unexpected and annoying issue was spotlights from the neighbors stairs, polluting the ability to star gaze. We asked if they could turn them off and they could not—also a rental. The lower deck could have been a good escape but needs pruning. The photos/decription weren’t accurate. It DID have shampoo and essentials, no pets but had pet supplies. We ran out of toilet paper and paper towel before our last day and had to buy more. Hot tub is smelly but might have been a dead rodent under the deck. NO privacy in the loft/primary bedroom. BIG cabin vibes, which we appreciated. Would probably stay there again.”
airbnb
JenniferJune 2026Fennville, Michigan
“The house gave us plenty of room to spread out. You can tell it has been constructed at different times. The kitchen is dated and narrow. The dishwasher doesn't line up to close. You can just tell that the very minimum is being done to rent this house. It's an amazing location but needs some TLC. We had been in town over a month before our rental and while walking on the road, we alerted the company that the fire pit was merely a few stones in the ground and wasn't really a pit anymore and that the picnic table was falling apart and instead of fixing the issues by our arrival, they told us we "were trespassing". We were unimpressed by the company and the lack of fixing things in the house. My husband had to open the cooling vents so the house could cool down. It was disappointing for the price tag.”
airbnb
OwenJune 2026Fennville, Michigan
“Great home, nice neighborhood, but the proximity to the beach was misleading and the check in office was about a 20 minute drive from the house. Be prepared for a rockier shore than most of Lake Michigan. Otherwise a nice and clean space.”
airbnb

Local Rankings