Manager Review

McCall Cabins

McCall Cabins's guest rating of 4.72 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review McCall Cabins.

Recent guest reviews

ChristineAugust 2026Donnelly, Idaho
It was an amazing house, very clean and spacious. The faucet in the kitchen was loose as were the chairs at the dining room table. There was no cleaning supplies, no trash bags, and were unsure what was available. Otherwise, It was a great experience and we would definitely stay there again.
airbnb
JenniferAugust 2026Mccall, Idaho
Great place. Had a great time.
airbnb
TrentAugust 2026Donnelly, Idaho
We’ve stayed here before it’s a great location. Well furnished, beautiful interior, and gorgeous surroundings. Only a couple minutes to the boat launch.
airbnb
EmilyAugust 2026Mccall, Idaho
Really great location if you want to be close to McCall! The place is well stocked and is a charming cabin. There is no AC but fans & in-window units were provided!
airbnb
CassieJuly 2026Mccall, Idaho
The location was perfect for walking to everything. It wasn’t very clean, dusty and there were things left behind by the owner or whoever stayed last (bags of chips and candy wrappers under the upstairs bed).
airbnb
JohnJuly 2026Mccall, Idaho
Cozy home a short walk from the lake. great experience! look forward to rebooking
airbnb
JeffJune 2026Donnelly, Idaho
Great house and great location. Had resident deer in the backyard the whole trip. Kitchen and bbq were perfect for home cooked meals
airbnb
EricJune 2026Donnelly, Idaho
Beautiful building, rough hosting. The cabin is genuinely stunning — brand new, luxurious, a slice of paradise. On looks alone it's 5 stars. But it feels like it was finished the day before I arrived and no one had ever lived in it: blank walls, a Keurig with no pods, a spice rack with no salt. All the trappings of hospitality without the follow-through. A McMansion in paradise, but not yet a place that knows how to host. My checkout got complicated, and I'll own it — a work emergency plus a kayak I'd bought locally meant renting a trailer to haul out. The cleaner was completely gracious about it. Joel was the opposite: he showed up, and instead of offering a hand or any patience, threatened to call the sheriff on a paying guest over a few extra minutes with a trailer. That's not a host — that's a landlord looking for a reason. The bones are 5 stars, the hosting is 1. Two is the honest average. I'll take the hotel in town next time - keep the paradise, minus the threats.
airbnb
DeenaMay 2026Mccall, Idaho
This stay was dreamy. The house was clean, nicely decorated, but it was free of clutter. The kitchen was the most well-stocked airbnb kitchen I have stayed in. The views were unparalleled. Being right on the water was so nice. All of the large trees gave us a feeling of privacy. We will absolutely stay here again.
airbnb
RicardoApril 2026Mccall, Idaho
Pretty good place to stay
airbnb

Local Rankings