Manager Review

J & S Reeve Cottages

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review J & S Reeve Cottages.

Recent guest reviews

MorganOctober 2026Riverhead, New York
“It was a beautiful location- peaceful and tranquil. Sandra was extremely responsive and made sure we had everything we needed!”
airbnb
PatrickOctober 2026Riverhead, New York
“Perfect cottage for our family of 5! Sandra was so easy to communicate with the whole time!”
airbnb
OliviaSeptember 2026Riverhead, New York
“Sandra Jean was a lovely host! She was very accommodating of our group, helping us get the kayaks in and out of the water and giving us local recommendations. The grounds were truly gorgeous. I couldn't imagine a more perfect place to share a weekend with friends. Just be aware that when it rains, the wind blows a lot of rain into the screened-in porch, so don't leave any belongings out there.”
airbnb
MarinaAugust 2026Riverhead, New York
“We had such a wonderful stay! Sandy was incredibly friendly, communicative, and so kind to our kids. The house had everything we needed, and we absolutely loved the beautiful, peaceful grounds. Dinner on the screened-in porch with no bugs was a highlight! Our kids loved running around outside and seeing Sandy’s cats. Such a relaxing getaway—we can’t wait to come back!”
airbnb
GregAugust 2026Riverhead, New York
“What a wonderful place! The cottages are so beautiful, and the grounds are absolutely immaculate. John and Sandra are incredible hosts so attentive and thoughtful. They have everything, both inside and out, in flawless condition. We truly enjoyed our stay and would highly recommend it!”
airbnb
KellyJuly 2026Riverhead, New York
“We absolutely loved our stay at J&S Cottages! We utilized the boats every day with our 5 and 7 year old - there are tons of sandy beaches a short paddle from the cottage! The extra wide paddle boards are perfect to share with young kids. Such a fun escape! We recommend checking out the beautiful, family friendly farms and vineyards in the area, and picking up fruit and treats at one of the many farm stands nearby!”
airbnb
DaveJuly 2026Riverhead, New York
“Sandy’s place was a perfect getaway for us and our two small dogs! The property is beautifully maintained and all the amenities were as described. The AC worked really well, which was a life saver with the heat over 4th of July weekend. Would definitely stay again!”
airbnb
QuentinJune 2026Riverhead, New York
“Really beautiful place and perfect for a family, with plenty of outdoor space and a great BBQ area. The location is excellent — only a 10-minute drive to the beach and very convenient for exploring the surrounding area. The host was responsive, friendly, and super helpful throughout our stay. Highly recommend!”
airbnb
LiamMay 2026Riverhead, New York
“An amazing host and an amazing stay! Sandra was very responsive and friendly. She greeted us upon arrival to facilitate check-in. Very much recommend”
airbnb

Local Rankings