Manager Review

Island Club

Island Club's guest rating of 4.72 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review Island Club.

Recent guest reviews

KathyOctober 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“Great place to stay”
airbnb
RobertOctober 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“Great place. Perfect for PIB. Highly recommend”
airbnb
EmilySeptember 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“Such a big and beautiful space. Quiet and a lovely welcoming community. Everything was extremely clean and our group was able to feel right at home!”
airbnb
VirginiaSeptember 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“We were only there for a day, but really enjoyed it and are already planning to bc one back and want to stay there again.”
airbnb
MohammadSeptember 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“Everything was as described. The entire house was very clean and smelt good no complaints. Would stay here again.”
airbnb
SagarSeptember 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“TV wasn't working. Other than that it was good. Not much of patio or sitting area outside with view.”
airbnb
HarshalSeptember 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“Could have been good if they had shower gels, shampoo and hair dryer since they are charging $100 for linens.”
airbnb
ChrisAugust 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“Place was ok..clean and somewhat new! But..doors don't close..hardware doesn't line up. Living room is the best..bathrooms not good at all..lipstick on a pig..if you know what I mean! Uneven floors..stubbed my toe on a register that is sticking up. Is it ok..Yes...is it worth the money..in my opinion..No!”
airbnb
WhitneyJuly 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“No towels at an Air B&B for 8 females”
airbnb
KatieMay 2026Put-In-Bay, Ohio
“I've never left a negative review, but future guests should know what to expect. The space was tidy, but beds were uncomfortable, towels were in poor condition, and we were up all night due to animals scratching in the walls. The booking process was frustrating — we were charged extra fees outside Airbnb and required to print a paper confirmation to check in, none of which was communicated upfront. The on-site contact was unwelcoming; when we asked where to check in, he said "in Cleveland." There was no communication between the main office and this location. We followed every checkout instruction: cleaned dishes, took out trash, left the place spotless, and even left food for on-site workers as requested. We still received a negative review — which is what prompted this one. I'd look elsewhere.”
airbnb

Local Rankings