Manager Review

Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review Historic Key West Vacation Rentals.

Recent guest reviews

MichelleAugust 2026Key West, Florida
Overall, we enjoyed our stay and really appreciated that the property was pet-friendly and that the hosts were accommodating in allowing us to bring our dog. The location was a major reason we chose this rental, and it was very convenient, especially having easy access to take our dog outside late at night. The hosts were very communicative and did check in on us throughout our stay, which we appreciated. The process for bringing our dog was more detailed than what we’ve experienced at other pet-friendly rentals, including providing her rabies vaccination records and tracker information, but we understand that every property has its own policies and requirements. There was also an unexpected situation involving a tree that had apparently been struck by lightning, which caused some commotion during our stay. We ended up contacting the police because we weren’t aware that anyone else had done so. The hosts did check in with us afterward, which we appreciated. A couple of things to kee
airbnb
AmandaAugust 2026Key West, Florida
This was a wonderful place to stay! It was so clean and well maintained! Thank you!
airbnb
KyleAugust 2026Key West, Florida
Great overall stay! Home was well maintained and had extremely helpful hosts that answered any questions. 10/10 would stay again.
airbnb
Renee WiseAugust 2026Key West, Florida
Wonderful stay for our honeymoon. They even left us a beautiful cake in the refrigerator for our honeymoon. Close proximity to everything
airbnb
LisaAugust 2026Key West, Florida
Beautiful house just as described. The pool was refreshingly cool, not hot! Took a dip multiple times after long hot excursions. Minimal clean up at check out. Would definitely book again.
airbnb
PerryAugust 2026Key West, Florida
This place is gorgeous. It is full of the owner's incredible art work. She lives upstairs and is a delightful human being. It is very quiet, though just a few blocks from bustling Duval St. I would go back in a heartbeat.
airbnb
ZackJuly 2026Key West, Florida
A+ Highly recommended!
airbnb
GregJuly 2026Key West, Florida
Had a great time. Thank you
airbnb
ToddJuly 2026Key West, Florida
Amazing!!! Loved the semi private pool, everything better than in the photos. Perfect walkable to the best parts of Key West. Don’t need a car just short uber/lyft from airport. hosts are super flexible and helpful. 100% recommend!!! We’ll be back. My fiance and I are in our 40s. Perfect 5 days for us.
airbnb
CodiJuly 2026Key West, Florida
Great little place to vacation centrally located extremely clean and friendly.
airbnb

Local Rankings