Manager Review

Amelia Island Rentals

Amelia Island Rentals's guest rating of 4.45 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review Amelia Island Rentals.

Recent guest reviews

HannahMay 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
we had a great time at this place. it is super close to the beach and only 10 minutes or so from downtown fernindina!
airbnb
VadimMay 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
The location is excellent, with easy access to the beach and nearby attractions, and the apartment itself was clean and well maintained. Check-in was smooth, and overall the space was comfortable for our stay. During our visit, we did notice some water along one of the walls after a storm, and we heard from others in the building that similar issues had occurred. It didn’t significantly disrupt our stay, but it’s something to be aware of. Overall, a good option in a great location with a minor issue that management may want to address.
airbnb
ElizabethApril 2026Amelia Island, Florida
Amelia Island Plantation is peaceful and walkable with beautiful surroundings. The condo was comfortable for our family getaway and the owners were responsive to our questions. We will be back to Amelia!
airbnb
EmilyMarch 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Great location. Easy boardwalk walk to the beach. Pool is nice. Wished there were a few more amenities — shampoo, conditioner, nicer towels. Comfy beds, comfy couches. Overall every product in the Airbnb is pretty cheap but it was fine for our stay. Would recommend.
airbnb
BenjaminMarch 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
I had a lovely stay here. Walking distance to almost everything on the Omni property and most importantly the beach.
airbnb
TravisMarch 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Would happily stay again.
airbnb
FrederickMarch 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
My family and I had a wonderful stay over my son’s spring break. The condo had everything we needed and the location was extremely walkable. Would definitely stay again!
airbnb
GeoffreyMarch 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Great place!
airbnb
BradMarch 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Mostly positive stay but not because of this unit. We had water supply shutoff to building several times during the 5 days… but nothing was communicated. The pool was closed for maintenance as well. The master bathroom is the size of a closet so the main bathroom was used most times. The mattresses are old, noisy and uncomfortable.
airbnb
March 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
A great place just a few hundred feet from beach access. Nice decor, two parking spots, great kitchen, walk to a couple of restaurants. We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves!
airbnb

Local Rankings