Manager Review

Amelia Island Rentals

Amelia Island Rentals's guest rating of 4.48 is below average and may adversely impact performance. Some of this can come from specific properties they manage — but where reviews point to manager weaknesses (responsiveness, cleanliness, listing accuracy) that would apply to your home too, they can adversely affect your bookings and the quality of guests you attract.

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review Amelia Island Rentals.

Recent guest reviews

LaurenJuly 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Close to the beach. Nice enclosed back porch. Very clean and pretty. Had a great time!
airbnb
MelisaJuly 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Exactly like the photos!! Place has been kept up well. Very comfortable beds and furniture. Views were breathtaking. Nightly visit from a tortoise. Super close to pool and deck to get to the beach!! Very peaceful and beautiful. Would definitely recommend.
airbnb
ReinhardtJuly 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Great condo for my family trip!
airbnb
TonyaJuly 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Beautiful house with all the amenities we wanted and needed for a relaxing beach vacation.
airbnb
RondaJune 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
The villa is beautifully renovated, very private, and in a great location within the Omni Resort. The villa has a single family house feel and parking is right in front. We will definitely stay there again when accommodations on the island are needed.
airbnb
DorseyJune 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
A happy bungalow. Easy walk to the beach, and to the Ritz where my conference was being held.
airbnb
NolanJune 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Excellent location and unit. Great for families. There are a lot of stairs, but baby gates are provided for small children. We had a great stay!
airbnb
WendyJune 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Wonderful home for a beach getaway. A unique feature of this home is that it feels like a treehouse in a beach town. The surrounding trees offer beauty and privacy. Well stocked kitchen. Plenty of towels and linens. 3 beach chairs (so if you need more, bring them). Comfy beds. Wonderful screen porch. Turn the fan on for a nice breeze. One block off the beach. Bring bikes if you like bike paths. Amelia island is beautiful.
airbnb
JohnApril 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
The good news is the location, right on a beautiful beach near the Ritz-Carlton, had a nice pool and was well landscaped. The condo building is a little dated but our condo had been renovated probably within the last 10 years. We only had 3 people in a 2 bed/bath condo, which was fine but I imagine 4 people would be a little tight. The kitchen is very tight for 2 people. The downside was a slight musty smell when you enter; no beach chairs, beach towels or umbrellas (in a beach condo?!?); no hair dryers (rental mgr bought next day); a master bath with poor water pressure and barely hot enough water; and in the morning we could hear children running around in the condo above us. We asked the rental mgr to reimburse us for the missing beach equipment we had to buy, but they refused - claiming most renters steal the towels and/or bring their own. Kind of tough to bring beach chairs and umbrellas on an airplane. Overall, a nice small beach condos in south, but lacking some amenities
airbnb
BradMarch 2026Fernandina Beach, Florida
Mostly positive stay but not because of this unit. We had water supply shutoff to building several times during the 5 days… but nothing was communicated. The pool was closed for maintenance as well. The master bathroom is the size of a closet so the main bathroom was used most times. The mattresses are old, noisy and uncomfortable.
airbnb

Local Rankings