Manager Review

All Star Baseball Rentals

Verified Homeowner Reviews

Write a review

No homeowner reviews yet — be the first to review All Star Baseball Rentals.

Recent guest reviews

AmyAugust 2026Oneonta, New York
“The house was close to Allstar village , restaurants and a short ride to Cooperstown. Spacious with plenty of room to relax. Great communication with the hosts.”
airbnb
NicoleAugust 2026Oneonta, New York
“I stayed for a week while visiting Cooperstown All Star Village. It was close and conveniently located between the baseball fields and also down the block from downtown Oneonta. The house was as described and the hosts were responsive. They even left some gifts including local maple syrup and pins for pin trading!”
airbnb
JasonAugust 2026Oneonta, New York
“Perfect location for Cooperstown All Star Village. Everyone was great, super friendly and accommodating. Communication was perfect. I would HIGHLY recommend this home to anyone looking to come to the area, full stop. A+”
airbnb
Daniel,LewisAugust 2026Oneonta, New York
“This place was perfect for our stay! Nice gifts! Everything was perfect and they respond to any questions super fast! I highly recommend them for your sta! Super easy to get to All Star village and Nicks is in between such great food shopping close for whatever you need including Dicks which is helpful”
airbnb
Brian Van WagenerAugust 2026Oneonta, New York
“Nice place in a central location. Easy access to local restaurants (walking distance) and also grocery stores. About a 7-min drive to ASV, which allowed us to get our son home for naps and a decent shower during his tournament. Having laundry was huge. Host communicated clearly and set clear expectations, but was also flexible. Place was in good condition and cleaned well before our arrival. Was as shown in pictures. Not fancy, but comfortable and in good condition. Would definitely recommend.”
airbnb
TracyAugust 2026Oneonta, New York
“We stayed in the All Star Rentals, Main Lineup, Apartment 1 during our son’s week-long Cooperstown All Star experience. I would very highly recommend it!! The host was excellent and checked in on us shortly after arriving to make sure everything was going well. The 1-bedroom apartment was quite spacious, very clean, and it was a great convenience to have a full kitchen with updated appliances and a washer/dryer in the unit. All start-up supplies were provided and there were plenty of bath towels. The local pancake mix and syrup welcome gift was a nice touch. It was just a quick 10-minute drive to the All Star Village, and even closer to downtown Oneonta restaurants and shops. Would highly recommend this rental over a hotel – much more space and a nice place to relax in between games. To sum it up, we were very happy with this rental!”
airbnb
GregJuly 2026Oneonta, New York
“Check-in was easy, and the house was just as described, very clean and comfortable. Parking was convenient, and having a liquor store right across the street was a nice bonus. Our favorite restaurant was Asian Cuisine, which was just a couple of minutes away from the house. The host was extremely friendly, helpful, and responsive throughout our stay. My family and I would definitely recommend staying here!”
airbnb
YaderJuly 2026Oneonta, New York
“Great host thanks again.”
airbnb
CynthiaJuly 2026Oneonta, New York
“Clean place . Easy to communicate”
airbnb
ValerieJuly 2026Oneonta, New York
“Host was extremely proactive and made sure to reach out weeks before with recommendations and tips for our visit. The house is walkable distance to the downtown area which had a lot of restaurants and pubs to eat and hang out at. The home itself was very well kept and clean and when I had questions the hosts responded within minutes. Overall a great value and minutes from Cooperstown which was the main reason for our visit, I can’t express how convenient that was especially when your kiddos play until 2am in some cases! Thank you for a great stay!”
airbnb

Local Rankings